One of the subs I received recently was a Trivia item concerning the spotting of the Sony logo, except that the word was spelled SANY. I've been putting related product logos (e.g. Boca-Cola, Cantury 13) for the show in Allusions, arguing that the company misspelled it on purpose, so I rejected it. But the person made a case that goofs should be in Trivia and that it isn't a reference to media (books, movies, tv programs) and pointed to the guidelines as being clear about it.

Here's the verbiage from the Submission Guidelines.
----
Trivia

Trivia is any small detail or goof that might not be known to people who view an episode. Trivia is attached at the episode level, not the show level. It should be specific to what aired in the episode and not deal with off-camera events, which should be submitted in the "notes" form. A car license-plate number is trivia, and a producer walking off the set is a note. (Back)

Allusions

Allusions: An allusion is an indirect or passing reference to an existing form of media, be it to another TV program, a movie, a piece of music, or a book. Allusions are prevalent in television shows, and some shows, like The Family Guy, make extensive use of this kind of humor. When submitting allusions, always credit the original media being referenced with as much detail as possible. (Back)
----

So where does it belong? :-/

I think this should go into Allusions. Even though it's misspelled, it's instantly recognized as the Sony logo. (Another example of this is the WacDonald's from Inu-yasha) It's an indirect reference to an existing form of media, in this case a logo, which is a form of advertising.

You should have the submitter resubmit it as an Allusion, IMO.

I would say Trivia. An image or a name uttered/visible that refers to something corporate or a celebrity, by definiton, goes there.

I do think Trivia and Allusion definitions need more clarification though for all editors as I think there is a great deal of confusion for stuff like this that falls in the grey areas....

I probably would have put it in trivia, but now I'm thinking about it. In the case of Sany, I don't know if I would think too much about it (mainly because I would just consider 'Sany' a brand name existing within the realm of the series), but suddenly I started thinking about an old Treehouse of Horror episode of The Simpsons where a character has The Shinning rather than The Shining (and they actually joke on-air about copyright issues). In that case, it would clearly be an allusion ... even though the fact that he has it is trivia. There does still seem to be a huge gray area as to what is what. I finally gave up on a lot of things and went with what it ultimately is. If it is a production note, it goes in notes -- no exceptions. (I know there are editors who want production notes in trivia, but I just can't do it.) The allusions still trip me up from time to time because sometimes there's something that deserves to be there put doesn't really fit, so I usually take a few minutes to find a way that it does fit if I really want it in there.

I believe it depends on the context. In khaki's example there's a line of dialogue that easily converts to allusion. If the item is stand alone - no line or obvious reference to it in the episode - I think a mention in trivia might be more appropriate. Now we're into that gray area... but a blurb such as "the stereo on the shelf reads SANY, possibly a legal dodge around SONY" or something like that could be used. IMO this falls under the "small detail" part of the trivia definition given.

An allusion, to me, requires a specific reference. Usually this is dialogue, but sometimes an action will also make the association. If it's just part of the props it's significance is minimal to nothing. The only time I don't have something from the episode attached to an allusion is when it's an episode title.

First: I basically agree with jekyll.

Second: If it is important to the story, it clearly belongs to the Allusion section, since it is not a goof! It is made intentional - a goof is baiscally an accident.

So such things are just a reference to the real world and would be an alluison, when it even has to be mentioned / is important.

But trivia isn't always goofs. The "small detail" portion of the guideline encompasses things like the home address of the characters, contents of a note briefly shown, that type of thing. If it's prominent but not referenced I think it could fit into the trivia section.

That said, since this is all a beastly gray area we're wading through, the editor would certainly be within bounds to deny if he/she didn't think it was important. It's just if he/she agrees with the submitter on its importance, then a placement in trivia would be the answer, IMO.