CNET Networks Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | SportsGamer | MP3.com | TV.com | Metacritic
Score: 9.4 Superb 168 votes

Why We Fight

Episode Number: 9    Season Num: 1    First Aired: Sunday October 28, 2001    Prod Code: n/a
Originally aired: Sunday October 28, 2001 on HBO
Writer: Erik Jendresen
Director: Phil Alden Robinson
Show Stars: Michael Cudlitz (Denver 'Bull' Randleman), Matthew Settle (Capt. Ronald Spiers), Philip Barantini (Wayne 'skinny' Sisk), James McAvoy (Pvt. James Miller), Rick Warden (II) (1st Lt. Harry Welsh), Matthew Leitch (Floyd 'Tab' Talbert), Nolan Hemmings (Charles 'Chuck' Grant), Nicholas Aaron (Robert E 'popeye' Wynn), Peter Youngblood Hills (Darrell C 'shifty' Powers), Robin Laing (Edward J 'babe' Heffron), Mark Huberman (Pvt. Lester 'Leo' Hashey), Peter McCabe (IV) (Cpl Donald Hoobler), Tom Hardy (Pfc. John Janovec), Phil McKee (Major Robert L Strayer), Shane Taylor (Eugene G 'doc' Roe), Ron Livingston (Capt. Lewis Nixon), Scott Grimes (T/Sgt. Donald Malarkey), Donnie Wahlberg (2nd Lt. C. Carwood Lipton), Neal McDonough (1st Lt. Lynn "Buck" Compton), Ross McCall (Joseph D Liebgott), Frank John Hughes (S/Sgt. William "Wild Bill" Guarnere), Rick Gomez (George Luz), Kirk Acevedo (SSgt. Joseph Toye), James Madio (Frank J Perconte), Richard Speight Jr. (Warren 'Skip' Muck), Dale Dye (Colonel Robert Sink), Damian Lewis (Richard D. Winters), Dexter Fletcher (John)
Guest Stars: Christian Malcolm (Military Policeman)

The men of Easy Company come face to face with the horrors of the Holocaust in "Why We Fight," the ninth installment of the HBO miniseries Band of Brothers.

The episode opens with the company in Germany, where they find no enemy resistance. In fact, they find warm beds and hot meals in the houses they commandeer. Many of the men go about looting the German homes and farms for food and valuables. Spiers (Matthew Settle) is particularly industrious, sending several shipments home. At least one soldier is lucky enough to bed down with a willing Fraulein.

A new replacement, O'Keefe (Matt Hickey) arrives, and gets a typically cool reception from the veterans. Major Winters (Damian Lewis) is keeping a close eye on his friend, Nixon (Ron Livingston), who was recently involved in a jump in which nearly all the troops were killed. To make matters worse, Nixon gets the news that his wife is divorcing him. He starts devoting all of his energy to tracking down bottles of his favorite booze. It's clear to these men that the war is almost over, and they discuss their plans. Liebgott (Ross McCall) talks about going back to the cab company and finding "a nice Jewish girl," while Webster (Eion Bailey) plans to finish school at Harvard.

The men have grown increasingly cynical about what they've accomplished in Europe. Then they make a gruesome discovery -- a small concentration camp in the woods of Landsberg. Several of these combat-hardened veterans break down when they see the condition of the prisoners. Winters and his men are shocked to learn that the men who have been starved and murdered at the camp are not criminals, but Jews, Poles, and Gypsies. In a tragic twist of irony and to the dismay of the soldiers and the detainees as well, the soldiers are ordered to re-lock the gates in order to contain all the victims until the U.S. military could fully help them.

advertisement
Click Here

Episode Vital Stats

 
Episode: Why We Fight
Season Number: 1
Episode Reviews: 7
Episode
Score:
9.4 Superb 168 votes
Rating Statistics:
perfect: 80 (47.6%)
superb: 71 (42.3%)
great: 9 (5.4%)
abysmal: 5 (3%)
Other: 3 (1.8%)
Your Why We Fight Score
This content requires Macromedia Flash Player 7 or higher. Get Flash
Review This Episode Contribute

Top Contributors

 
Retired Canadinbcn
Score: 444 points
Retired Mafeu
Score: 334 points
bacardi17
Score: 73 points
Angelwomyn
Score: 60 points
trustno1files
Score: 30 points
Doc__Roe
Score: 21 points
dju010
Score: 19 points
Hal_10000
Score: 16 points
dmarex
Score: 15 points
ReachOut-TvTome
Score: 13 points