So number three is convinced that she has seen the Final Five, and has shown Balter sketches of what they look like. In the sketches, there seems to be 3 women and 2 men. If that is the case, that would make the final tally 6 male and 6 female models. But so far only 7 of the models have been revealed:

Number 3
Number 5
Number 6
Number 8
Leoben Conoy
Simon
Cavil

Who do you think could be a cylon? Someone entirely new? Or someone who has infiltrated Galactica?

I think it's someone higher up than that. It's obvious even the Cylons themselves are kept from knowing who they are, there must be a reason for this. A spy planted in the Galactica, I really think Tom Zarek is one playing the opposite field.

We pretty much estalbished on other threads that jammer is not a clyon

but i do agree that someone improtant is actually a cylon

If Cylon agents appeared 2 years ago, Gaeta can't be Cylon as he's been working under Adama command for more than 4 years.

I believe RDM has said on one of the podcasts (or maybe an interview, I can't remember) That the cylons are not based on existing humans, but rather types of humans, not just in looks but in personality. It's true though, we have no idea how long the Cylons have been mucking about with Skin jobs. Adama is almost certainly out though, mainly for the reasons that:

1) Skin Jobs not based on existing humans. 2) He's a decorated veteran of 45 years, and was in the first Cylon war, certainly before they ever had human-cylons
3) If they reveal such a thing it would totally destroy the premise of the spin off series that's being worked on.

Just my 2˘.

I didn't know that, sry. That thread is really huge, and I just wanted to see what people thought about these five people in a simple poll.

The only way I can come up with a plasable theory is with deductive reasoning.  These were some rather interesting suspects but only one can logically be a cylon.  It can't be Helo because after all the baby Shanon and Helo had was a hybrid.  It's not Baltar, since he was the one person the cylons were able to manipulate easily into that genocide attack, if he was a cylon they wouldn't have to.  Felix Gata is out, if he was a cylon he would of been some double agent in New Caperica but he wasn't because none of the resistance moves were ever compromised whenever he passed out information, except for Sol's wife in one battle.  Chief Tyrol no way, after all if he was a cylon he would have unconcously sabatoshed the Rapters he always repairs or at least affect the outcome in one battle or two, plus what about that child he had with Calie.  It has to be a new player in the game, it most of the time is whenever the cylons infiltrate so it's got to be Anastasia Dualla.  At least that's what I think, I'd love to hear any theories that think differently if anyone does.

sh811a wrote:

The only way I can come up with a plasable theory is with deductive reasoning. These were some rather interesting suspects but only one can logically be a cylon. It can't be Helo because after all the baby Shanon and Helo had was a hybrid. It's not Baltar, since he was the one person the cylons were able to manipulate easily into that genocide attack, if he was a cylon they wouldn't have to. Felix Gata is out, if he was a cylon he would of been some double agent in New Caperica but he wasn't because none of the resistance moves were ever compromised whenever he passed out information, except for Sol's wife in one battle. Chief Tyrol no way, after all if he was a cylon he would have unconcously sabatoshed the Rapters he always repairs or at least affect the outcome in one battle or two, plus what about that child he had with Calie. It has to be a new player in the game, it most of the time is whenever the cylons infiltrate so it's got to be Anastasia Dualla. At least that's what I think, I'd love to hear any theories that think differently if anyone does.

These are all very sounds arguments. The problem is that no one knows anything about the final five, not even the other 7 cylons. So, in truth all of these characters could be cylons. In fact, Helo and Cheif could be cylons too because for all we know the final five can reproduce normally.

I think Dee is the cylon.  Didn't someone once say that "Adama is a cylon"?  Well, Dee married Lee and now she's an Adama.  Add in all the other evidence against her... 

i guess we will have to wait and see