One of Hobie's friends almost die while he surfs at a place known as "The Shredder". Mitch gets real shaken up about the incident and tells Hobie that he could have been the one who almost drowned. Mitch closes down that section of the beach to keep anyone else from being killed there. But Mitch's signs doesn't stop Hobie's friend Isaac from going there to surf. He thinks he will get his father's attention by doing so. Hobie tells Mitch about it and he and Stephanie are able to rescue Isaac before he injures himself badly. When Mitch tells Isaac's dad about it, he gets upset and tells Mitch to mind his own business and then he leaves headquarters.

The next day when Mr. Klein calls Mitch and Hobie and asks to speak with Isaac, Mitch figures out that something is wrong. Isaac didn't spend the night in their home. Mitch asks Mr. Klein to meet him at "The Shredder". When Mitch arrives, he is able to rescue Isaac just in time. After this incident, Isaac and his parents start with therapy to solve their problems. While, Isaac, Mr. Klein, Mitch and Hobie are playing football on the beach, Mr. Klein's secretary calls and tells him that he is needed at an important meeting. But instead he tells her that he is busy with his son.

Meanwhile, Caroline befriends an old jockey named Corey Berens on the beach. But she doesn't know who he is until Logan tells her. He tells her that he got blind during a race when he fell of his horse. When some kids get into trouble, Corey sees this and Caroline suspects that he just pretends to be blind. At the Sandy Cay Cafe, Caroline tells Nicole, one of the waitresses, to spill ice coffee on her hand. Corey who thinks that the coffee is warm, asks if she got burned. Then Caroline knows for sure that Corey can see.

Confronted by Caroline, he admits that he pretended to be blind because he is afraid to race again. Caroline convinces him to start riding again on his horse Dakotashan who ended up with a broken leg after the fall. Now when both Corey and Dakotashan has recuperated, Corey is provoked by Lance Kincaid, the jockey responsible for Corey's accident. Corey challenges Kincaid for a race on the beach. The winner gets the loser's horse. Of course Corey ends up winning and is now back for good.