Segment 1: "The Hand" - In a bar called the Bloody Hand, named after a brutal murder of a woman whose only remains found were her bloody hand, a drifter finds the hand is pointing at him. Is it a practical joke or is he the killer?
Segment 2: "The Battered Doll" - A maid kills her employers and claims innocence until one of the prize possessions of the mistress, tells otherwise. The only problem it's a doll.
Segment 3: "Poker Justice" - In the early 1900s, in an Irish bar, three poker players kill another one when he's revealed to be a cheat, and the only way to get back their losings is to enlist the aid of a "good man". They give the winnings to a boy found in the church and precede to play poker with him to win their money back. The only problem is that he's good and proceeds to win more of their money! Is he a cheat too?
Segment 4: "Above the Clouds" - Melanie continues to have a dream where she is trapped in an elevator and it terrifies her. When she must travel in an elevator with her friends, she must face her fears when it stops and they're trapped. Is this a premonition or a coincidence?
Segment 5: "Screen Saver" - A man and a woman break up after 5 years and the woman moves across the country to California. A year goes by and when she goes to repair her computer, returns home to find a screen saver of a picture of her and her old boyfriend. Is this a cosmic coincidence or a plan?