Cold Case: Boy in the Box

Episode score 8.9 Great

Boy in the Box

  • 14.
  • Season: 1
  • Episode: 14
  • First Aired: 2/15/2004
  • Prod Code: 176712

EPISODE OVERVIEW

3 Reviews | 90 Votes

The 1958 death of an unknown 6-year-old boy found in a field inside a cardboard box is reinvestigated after a small suitcase with the child's picture and his old cowboy hat is left in front of a church. The new probe reveals that the rowdy boy lived at a Catholic-run orphanage and was adopted two days before his suspicious demise. Read full recap »

Writers:
Meredith Stiehm
Director:
Karen Gaviola
Stars:
Jeremy Ratchford (Det. Nick Vera)
Danny Pino (Scotty Valens)
Thom Barry (Det. Will Jeffries)
John Finn (Lt. John Stillman)
Kathryn Morris (Det. Lilly Rush)
Recurring Role:
Marisol Nichols (Elisa)
Guest Star:
Autumn Reeser (Sister Grace (1958))
Samantha Eggar (Sister Vivian (2003))
Johanna Watts (Sister Vivian (1958))
Blaire Restaneo (Gretchen (1958))
Molly Cheek (Gretchen (2003))
Lyndon Smith (Arnold (1958))
Garrett M. Brown (Roger (2003))
Andrew Heald (Roger/"Cowboy" (1958))
Charles Noland (Walter (2003))
Dave Michael Beaudrie (Walter (1958))
Brent Schraff (Dr. Thayer (1958))
Delaney Williams (Fred Baker (1958))
Justin Roney ("Indian" (1958))
Jason Frasca (Young Man (1958))
Ryan Tasz (Clayton Weathers (1958))
Jacqueline Scott (Sally Bower (2003))
Bruce Gray (Dr. Thayer (2003))
Gathering Marbet (Young Woman (1958))
  • Arnold died on April 4, 1958. edit »
  • Goof: Sister Vivian says that Sister Grace was pregnant at age 18. However, according to the tombstones, Grace was born in 1936 and Arnold in 1952, which would have made Grace 16 when Arnold was born. edit »
  • Sister Vivian: Sister Grace... She wasn't a good nun.
    Scotty: No kidding. edit »
  • Det. Rush: Do you know Clayton Weathers?
    Sister Vivian: He was Grace's ruin. edit »
  • Sister Vivian: There are no cows in the woods.
    Arnold: That's what you think! edit »
  • Det. Rush: Could Grace have hurt Arnold?
    Sister Vivian: Grace? Some stories shouldn't be told. edit »
  • Fred Banks: Sister Vivian was pretty cruel... but murder? edit »
  • The Boy in the Box
    This episode has many very close similarities to the real-life "The Boy in the Box" case. In 1957, an anonymous boy was found in a box, wrapped in a blanket in Fox Chase, Philadelphia. Many of the items and contents of this episode bear striking resemblance to the posters made to help try to identify this boy, including propping the slain child up in clothes. The real case remains unsolved to this day, although the town he was found near raised the money to give him a proper burial. edit »
Show Score 8.9 great
  • Show Statistics
  • 485 of 17,820 Rating Rank
  • 149 Reviews
  • 5,012 Tracked by
  • 3,560 Votes
advertisement

top contributors

  • Avatar of Talvix

    Talvix

    emblem
    • user score: 3942
    • last online: Nov 18, 2008
  • Avatar of Frostelized

    Frostelized

    emblem
    • user score: 239
    • last online: Nov 19, 2008
  • Avatar of Frostelized

    Frostelized

    emblem
    • user score: 239
    • last online: Nov 19, 2008
  • Avatar of Robynette

    Robynette

    emblem
    • user score: 219
    • last online: Feb 20, 2008
  • Avatar of Angelwomyn

    Angelwomyn

    • user score: 176
    • last online: Nov 18, 2008
  • Avatar of ahmetyal

    ahmetyal

    • user score: 114
    • last online: Oct 18, 2008
  • Avatar of flame_tiger86

    flame_tiger86

    • user score: 92
    • last online: Nov 19, 2008
advertisement