CNET Networks Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | SportsGamer | MP3.com | TV.com | MovieTome
Score: 9.2 Superb 291 votes

Happenstance

Episode Number: 149    Season Num: 7    First Aired: Thursday November 16, 2006    Prod Code: 708
Identical twins are found murdered on the same night. The CSI’s investigate the two separate murders only to find a twist in the investigation find that leads them in another new direction.

Cast and Crew

Add Cast | Add Crew
Writer: Sarah Goldfinger
Director: Jean de Segonzac
Star: William Petersen (Gil Grissom),  Robert David Hall (Dr. Al Robbins (episode 47+, recurring previously)),  Paul Guilfoyle (Captain Jim Brass),  Marg Helgenberger (Catherine Willows),  Louise Lombard (Sofia Curtis (episode 142+, recurring previously)),  Jorja Fox (Sara Sidle (episode 2+)),  George Eads (Nick Stokes),  Gary Dourdan (Warrick Brown),  Eric Szmanda (Greg Sanders (episode 47+, recurring previously))
Recurring Role: Liz Vassey (Wendy Simms),  Wallace Langham (David Hodges),  Archie Kao (Archie Johnson),  David Berman (David Phillips)
Guest Star: Sheeri Rappaport (Mandy Webster),  Joanna Going (Amanda Sinclair),  Maxwell Huckabee (Henry Sinclair),  Valerie Mahaffey (Dora Pomerantz),  Saige Thompson (Tiffany Hughes),  Sarai Givaty (Natal Peled),  Harry Van Gorkum (Jake Lenoir),  Joanna Going (Jill Case),  J.C. MacKenzie (Dr. Gus Hoffman),  Kelly Smith (Allison Shram),  Frank Grillo (Gary Sinclair)

Notes

add »
Featured Music:
Two Of A Kind by Bobby Darin & Johnny Mercer
Mandy by Barry Manilow
When Nick Sings.
Word Up by Willis (edit)
CSI rating beat Grey's two weeks in a row. This episode had highest ratings for this season. Read here- http://www.tv.com/tracking/viewer.html?tid=98386&ref_id=19&ref_type=101 (edit)
Hodges refers to the victim's car as having been damaged by "the sabra's key". "Sabra" is a term used to describe a native-born Israeli (Natal, in this case); it literally means "prickly pear". (edit)
In this episode, Nick (George Eads) sings Barry Manilow's Mandy to Mandy Webster (Sheeri Rappaport) to get some lab results. (edit)

Quotes

add »
Doctor: She's the kind of girl we like to call a bed pan.
Nick: A bed pan?
Doctor: Yeah, full of crap and best when dumped. (edit)
Wendy: I have bad news and weird news. Which would you like to hear first?
Catherine: Bad.
Wendy: Bad news, I got nothin' from the blue stocking that was found in trash. Weird news, I tested the red lipstick that was found on the Gary Sinclair's collar, and I got DNA but it wasn't his wife's.
Catherine: Well, based on the contents of her purse she's more of the lip balm type.
Wendy: Well, you know I like to be through. I ran it through COTIS and I actually got a hit, Natal Peled. She's in the system for a rape charge in L.A.
Catherine: They don't put victim's DNA in the database.
Wendy (smirks): No, they don't. (Catherine looks intrigued) Yeah, I had to know so I called a friend of mine from the L.A Sheriff's department. And apparently Natal was a nurse from a Hollywood hospital and she went to the annual Christmas party she fed this doctor a buncha cocktails, (Catherine looks shocked and starts to smile) slipped him a provalice and then took him to a hotel room. Rumor has it was to have unprotected, (smiles) you know, baby-makin' sex. He pressed charges, she was arrested and then they settled out of court. And now Natal's a nurse at our very own Desert Palm.
Catherine: With Amanda's husband---Dr. Gary Sinclair. (edit)
Catherine: Our two cases have become one.
Grissom: Could still be two cases.
Catherine (smirks): Whatever happened to Mr. No-Such-Thing-As-Coincidence? "The simplest hypothesis is usually the correct one." "If you hear hooves think horses, not zebras."
Grissom: What would the horses be in this case?
Catherine: Murder/suicide. Jill killed Amanda, and then felt guilty and killed herself.
Grissom: And what've you got to support that?
Catherine: Did you notice any photos of Amanda or Amanda's family at Jill's house?
Grissom: No.
Catherine: Right. And I looked through Amanda's phone book and Jill was not even in it.
Grissom: Well, maybe she her number memorized.
Catherine: Brass spoke to Jill's attorney for next of kin--non-existant. She leaving a small fortune to various charities. Sounds to me like estrangement. (Grissom makes a face) Okay, even if that wasn't the exact way that it went down I'll bet you a dollar that the twins deaths are related.
Grissom: Two women found dead on opposite sides of town, if they didn't look alike would you still link them?
Catherine: If they're relatives, yes. Sisters, husband and wife, father and son.
Grissom: Okay.
Catherine: Okay, what?
Grissom: I'll take the bet. (edit)
Warrick: Boy, she hung out with some big wigs.
Grissom: She was a big wig. Jill Case editor and chief of the Las Vegas Globe, she was a wonder kid. One of the youngest women in history to run a newspaper.
Brass: Well, I've been all around the house, no sign of a forced entry.
Grissom: Consistent with suicide.
Warrick (looking at suicide note): So is this. You can't even use a whole sheet of paper for your suicide note?
Grissom: Well, I don't know. If you feel like you don't deserve to take up space on the planet, you don't deserve a whole piece of paper. (edit)
Catherine: Well, I got a phone, and keys but no purse.
Nick: Mugging?
Catherine: Take the purse but leave the Lexus?
Nick: Yeah, that's not real savvy, is it? (edit)

Trivia

add »
When Curtis and Stokes go to visit Mrs. Palmerand at the horse farm to ask her about her twins, she leads the horse to the post to tie it to while she talks to the CSI's. She takes the horse lead and drapes it around the post a few times, which a true horse handler would never do. They would tie a simple slip knot to ensure that the rope won't fall away to easily letting the horse roam free. (edit)
When Catherine is talking to Grissom she says:

Catherine (smirks): Whatever happened to Mr. No-Such-Thing-As-Coincidence? "The simplest hypothesis is usually the correct one." "If you hear hooves think horses, not zebras."

Grissom said this same line in Season 6 episode Pirates of the Third Reich:
Grissom: Occam's Razor, principle of parsimony. If you hear hoof beats think horses, not zebras. (edit)
The word that Grissom missed on the crossword was "misanthrope" meaning "distruster of the human race." Hmm, who do we know that sounds like this? (edit)
In the beginning of the episode, we see Grissom looking at a letter that mentions an entomology seminar, and it suggests that he take a sabbatical.

For a few episodes this season, William Petersen will be leaving the show in order to star in a play, and the on-air reason for Grissom's temporary leave is a sabbatical. (edit)

Allusions

add »
Grissom: She was a wunderkind.

From the German: Wunder = wonder/miracle & Kind = child, a child prodigy or someone who achieves overwhelming success very early in life. Wunderkinds have a greater tendency towards OCD due to their need to stay at the top of their field. (edit)
One of the sisters is called Jill Case, and she has a half sister called Tiffany. This is an allusion to the James Bond film "Diamonds Are Forever", part of which is set in Las Vegas. The female lead is Tiffany Case, played by Jill St John . (edit)
Dr. Hoffman: She was the 's' I was the 'm'.

This quote references the common S&M which is short for Sadism & Masochism. A sadist is someone derives pleasure, either emotional or sexual, from causing another human being or animal pain. A masochist is someone who derives pleasure, either emotional or sexual, from receiving pain. A sadist and a masochist are good together because one enjoys hurting the other, while the other enjoys being hurt by the other. (edit)
Warrick: When we checked the flash drive I found in Jill's drawer, we found more than meets the eye.
Greg: It's a Transformer?

Transformers are toys that fold out from everyday objects such as an animal or a car or other vehicle into robots. In the story universe (developed by Marvel Comics) that goes with the advertising, the robots are intelligent entities, the good (Autobots) fighting the evil (Decepticons).

The toys were developed in Japan by Takara Co. in the early 1980s and sold under licence in the US by Hasbro starting in 1984. The two main advertising taglines for Transformers were Robots in Disguise and More than meets the eye. (edit)
Tell the world what you think of Happenstance, write a review for this episode.
Write a Review

Community Reviews (16)

 
8.4
Great
Happenstance
"Tearjerker"
This was possibly the saddest show I've ever seen.
Continue » Posted May 13, 2008 3:29 pm PST
9.2
Superb
Happenstance
"Cleverly plotted"
Two identical twin sisters, who were split up by adoption and therefore never knew the other existed, are murdered on the same night just hours apart. The investigation takes a number of twists and turns on the way to it's conclusion.
Continue » Posted Jan 6, 2008 9:52 am PST
10.0
Perfect
Happenstance
"Exactly why I watch this series"
The CSIs investigate a double murder of two women who look alike, but then the cases become related.
Continue » Posted Dec 1, 2007 10:11 am PST
9.6
Superb
Happenstance
"Well written"
Identical twins are found dead at separate locations on the same night and the team must work out the connection...
Continue » Posted Jun 29, 2007 10:16 pm PST

ileanabrea
Report Abuse 1 user agrees
with this review
10.0
Perfect
Happenstance
"Adventurous"
I didn't understand this episode at all. Well, I did get the last 5 minutes.
Continue » Posted May 6, 2007 8:48 am PST
Previous Next
advertisement

Episode Vital Stats

 
Episode: Happenstance
Season Number: 7
Episode Reviews: 16
Episode
Score:
9.2 Superb 291 votes
Rating Statistics:
superb: 158 (54.3%)
perfect: 75 (25.8%)
great: 47 (16.2%)
good: 6 (2.1%)
Other: 5 (1.7%)
Your Happenstance Score
This content requires Macromedia Flash Player 7 or higher. Get Flash
Review This Episode Contribute

Top Contributors

 
Editor Joker00303
Score: 3,719 points
Retired jchamberlin
Score: 2,043 points
mini2z
Score: 764 points
Stig14
Score: 586 points
atwdave
Score: 488 points
addictedto
Score: 318 points
Edward_Nigma
Score: 295 points
csi1013
Score: 255 points
Maisy13
Score: 233 points
pagman_rox
Score: 210 points

Episode Downloads

 
CSI Episodes can be downloaded from these services:
Happenstance No. 149 season 7
1 iTunes Quicktime get download