CNET Networks Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | SportsGamer | MP3.com | TV.com | Metacritic
Score: 9.3 Superb 266 votes

You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover

Episode Number: 77    Season Num: 4    First Aired: Sunday November 11, 2007    Prod Code: 407
Lynette's sisters Lydia and Lucy come to visit. While having dinner with Susan and Mike, Bree and Orson realize they share different views on whether their newborn baby should be circumcised. On a boat, Victor confronts Gaby about her affair with Carlos and she throws him into the ocean. Later, Bree informs Susan that she thinks Mike is addicted to drugs.

Cast and Crew

Add Cast | Add Crew
Writer: Anne Flett-Giordano, Chuck Ranberg
Director: David Warren
Star: Brenda Strong (Mary Alice Young),  Andrea Bowen (Julie Mayer),  Ricardo Antonio Chavira (Carlos Solis),  Marcia Cross (Bree Hodge),  Nicollette Sheridan (Edie Britt),  Doug Savant (Tom Scavo),  Shawn Pyfrom (Andrew Van De Kamp),  Kyle MacLachlan (Orson Hodge),  Eva Longoria Parker (Gabrielle Lang),  Joy Lauren (Danielle Van De Kamp),  Felicity Huffman (Lynette Scavo),  Teri Hatcher (Susan Mayer),  Lyndsy Fonseca (Dylan Davis),  James Denton (Mike Delfino),  Dana Delany (Katherine Mayfair)
Recurring Role: John Slattery (Victor Lang),  Brent Kinsman (Preston Scavo),  Zane Huett (Parker Scavo),  Shane Kinsman (Porter Scavo)
Guest Star: Greg Lewis (Stan),  Julie Pop (Nurse),  Tom Beyer (Dr. Hanson),  Bob Glouberman (Mohel),  Carrie Preston (Lucy),  Polly Bergen (Stella Wingfield),  Sarah Paulson (Lydia Lindquist)

Notes

add »
International Air Dates:
Latin America: Wednesday, March 26, 2008 on Sony Entertainment Television.
Norway: Tuesday, April 1, 2008 on TV2
Germany: Wednesday, April 2, 2008 on ProSieben
Australia: Monday, April 7, 2008 on Seven
Netherlands: Tuesday, April 8, 2008 on Net5
Finland: Monday, April 21, 2008 on Nelonen
Sweden: Tuesday, April 22, 2008 on Kanal 5 (edit)
Danielle's baby is given the name Benjamin. (edit)
Although credited Shawn Pyfrom (Andrew Van De Kamp), Joy Lauren (Danielle Van De Kamp) and Rachel Fox (Kayla Huntington) do not appear in this episode. (edit)
Felicity Huffman and Sarah Paulson are friends in real life and they have appeared together before in Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip's Pilot; the episode The People vs. Achmed Abbas of the early canceled show The D.A and the TV-movie Path to War. (edit)
Carrie Preston also played Felicity Huffman's sister in the movie Transamerica. (edit)

Quotes

add »
Carlos calls Gabby on her cell phone while she's on the boat. She reluctantly answers.
Gabrielle: For God's sakes Carlos, am I gonna have to change this number?
Carlos: Victor knows!
Gabrielle: Knows what?
Carlos: Everything! Edie told him we're having an affair.
Gabrielle: No. it's impossible. He hasn't said a word. In fact, I've never seen him so sweet and attentive.
Carlos: It's an act! Edie said he was enraged!
Gabrielle: Well, if he's so mad at me, why would he take me on a boat trip?
Carlos: He took you on a boat?
Gabrielle: Oh crap! (edit)
After she knocked Victor overboard for a second time
Gabrielle: I'm getting pretty good at that. (edit)
Lucy: You may have been able to strong-arm the weak one, but not me.
Lydia: I'm not weak!
Lucy: Then why did you call me? Get out of our way.
Lynette: Lucy, every fight we have ever had has ended with my foot on your neck. I guarantee that this one's gonna end the same way too. (edit)
Lynette: (referring to her mother) Well, we can't just throw her out on the street.
Lydia: I can!
Lynette and Lucy look at her with surprise
Lydia: My therapist said it's time for me to be a little more Lydia-centric.
Lynette: I really wanna meet this jackass. (edit)
Lynette: (referring to her mother) I've had her for four months. I also had cancer for four months. And If I could've asked one of them to leave, I'm not sure which I would've picked.
Lucy: Oh, four months, boohoo! I had her for a year, and that was the year she joined the Gin of the Month club. (edit)

Trivia

add »
Although they never confirm which state this story is set in, this episode offers up that is a state that touches the ocean. (Victor states that he and Gaby are going out on the ocean in his boat.) Since Gaby was able to go back and forth at least twice in one day and the boat has FAIRVIEW on the back, it would strongly suggest that the fictitious "Eagle State" is on the West coast. (edit)
Bree (alledgedly) just gave birth only a few days earlier, yet is is up and about without any signs of wear or exhaustion. She also doesn't even try to pad her figure with post-pregnancy weight, which is very likely after giving birth to a third child, especially for a woman her age. Granted, her pregnancy is a hoax, but for someone who is concerned on pulling it off as accurately as possible, you'd think she would try to make the effort. (edit)
Timeline goof- In this episode, Bree and Mike discuss his accident at the end of Season two and mention that it was "almost two years ago". In these almost two years, Danielle has gone from being 3 months over 17 (considering Xiao-Mei's pregnancy) to turning 18. (edit)
Watch carefully during the scene in the diner with Lynette and her sister. Her sister's key chain moves across the table before Lynette touches it. (Presumably they did several takes of Lynette grabbing it and forget to place back where it was originally.) (edit)
Orson got circumcised when he was 5 years old. (edit)

Allusions

add »
Bree: My Grandma....Tzietel.

This is no doubt an allusion to the famous Jewish-oriented Broadway musical Fiddler On The Roof. (edit)
Bree: By the way, his [Benjamin's] Hebrew name is Simcha. (Answering Orson's wondering look) I'll explain later.

Simcha means happiness in Hebrew. It's a modern (not Biblical) Hebrew name. (edit)
The episode title "You Can't Judge A Book By It's Cover" is a song from the Stephen Sondheim musical "Anyone Can Whistle". (edit)
Tell the world what you think of You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover, write a review for this episode.
Write a Review

Community Reviews (17)

 
7.7
Good
You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover
"Average"
Bree and Orson clash over whether to get baby Benjamin circumcised, Susan confronts Mike over his drug taking, Lynnette tries to foist her mother onto her sisters, Katherine lies to her daughter and Gabby and Victor go on a boat trip.
Continue » Posted May 5, 2008 11:46 am PST
8.0
Great
You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover
"Adventurous"
Judgements Written by Chuck Ranberg And Anne Flett-Giordano Directed by David Warren
Continue » Posted Mar 27, 2008 10:47 am PST
9.9
Superb
You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover
"Nerve-wracking"
OMG!!!!!!!!! what is going on with Mike???????? Is Victor dead??????
Continue » Posted Nov 25, 2007 6:10 pm PST
10.0
Perfect
You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover
"Exactly why I watch this series"
Another great episode and this was explosive
Continue » Posted Nov 19, 2007 1:37 am PST
10.0
Perfect
You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover
"Revealing"
Loved it! I guess it takes a few extras (Lynette's Sisters) and a Bris to really spice things up, this was terrific. That and the fact that Gabby put Victor in the Ocean!
Continue » Posted Nov 17, 2007 8:22 am PST
Previous Next
advertisement

Episode Vital Stats

 
Episode: You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover
Season Number: 4
Episode Reviews: 17
Episode
Score:
9.3 Superb 266 votes
Rating Statistics:
superb: 115 (43.2%)
perfect: 92 (34.6%)
great: 42 (15.8%)
good: 10 (3.8%)
Other: 7 (2.8%)
Your You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover Score
This content requires Macromedia Flash Player 7 or higher. Get Flash
Review This Episode Contribute

Top Contributors

 
Editor Daniel777C
Score: 2,390 points
Retired TM56
Score: 1,542 points
vukcevic
Score: 496 points
jekyll
Score: 328 points
dragonbulldog
Score: 318 points
Mafeu
Score: 251 points
moiz89
Score: 224 points
alana15
Score: 221 points
radrobd
Score: 190 points
Leo75
Score: 181 points

Episode Downloads

 
Desperate Housewives Episodes can be downloaded from these services:
You Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover No. 77 season 4
1 iTunes Quicktime get download