Carol is infuriated when Dennis cancels the annual budget meeting for all faculty. The entire faculty bands together to get rid of Dennis, including writing his end of the first semester review. Carol convinces the faculty to give Dennis a chance to prove himself. When he later takes Carol to task for her actions, she investigates further, discovering he was fired. Carol writes him a positive evaluation, which Dennis tears up and returns. Frustrated by his continued rebuffs, she kisses him.

A young lawyer, Joe Baxter, fresh out of the corporate world and full of energy, requests to join Ed's "firm". He observes Ed for a while, and launches his own "bowling alley practice" complete with Kenny, Shirley, and Phil-esque characters in his employ, and going so far as to steal Ed's clients. He advertises himself as the world's first bowling alley lawyer. When push comes to shove, Joe cannot deliver in the court room, and Ed happily regains his status.

Ed gets involved in the Carol-Dennis tiff by helping Carol investigate Dennis's past on the internet. They discover he is a much loved figure in New England, where he was not only a teacher, but a coach, community service coordinator, and theater/drama coach.

Diane discovers the wrestling team needs a member at Warren's weight and encourages him to join the team, citing that all the popular guys in whom Jessica seems interested have varsity letters. When a teammate weighs in at the same weight, Warren faces a wrestle-off. Despite defeat, he manages to get in the first take-down, which earns him notice among Jessica's crowd.