Damon is too much the pretty boy without much substance, and although his eyes are a nice color (not sure they are not colored contacts) they don't talk to you like Eric's eyes do. He also just always looks the same where Eric has so many different expressions and such a witty sense of humor
Surprised Dex isn't on this list. I mean, are we talking supernatural monsters only? If so, alright...
Another tough one though. Josh Radcliff is adorkable for a monster, and it makes you sympathize with him... but Damon is one of those lovable jerks. Then you add Caroline to the list and only give us one choice? How cruel you are, tv.com staff!! How cruel indeed. Guess I'll pick a non-TVD entry, because those guys are getting ALL the love. This one is for you, Josh! *votes*
Damon all the way. It was hard not to select Eric...but Damon takes the cake all the way. Incidentally, Caroline Forbes does NOT belong in that list. She's easily one of the most annoying characters on TV.
Gaah, can't decide between Damon and Eric. They both remind me of my all time favorite character Spike (from Btvs). I want to support my fellow swede Alexander/Eric but at the same time Damon is such an interesting character.