CNET Networks Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | SportsGamer | MP3.com | TV.com | Metacritic
Score: 9.0 Superb 31 votes

Semi-Decent Proposal (1)

Episode Number: 189    Season Num: 8    First Aired: Tuesday May 15, 2001    Prod Code: 188
Frasier takes interest in a charming woman named Claire, who he meets in a store line. However, Claire turns out to be a friend of Lana's, and in order to spend time with her, Frasier must escort Lana to her surprise birthday party.

Cast and Crew

Add Cast | Add Crew
Writer: Lori Kirkland Baker
Director: Katy Garretson
Star: Kelsey Grammer (Dr. Frasier Crane),  Moose (Eddie),  John Mahoney (Martin Crane),  Peri Gilpin (Roz Doyle),  David Hyde Pierce (Dr. Niles Crane),  Jane Leeves (Daphne Moon Crane)
Recurring Role: Brian Klugman (Kirby),  Patricia Clarkson (Claire),  Jean Smart (Lana Gardner)
Guest Star: Lynndi Scott (Party Guest #2),  Michael Rothhaar (Party Guest #1),  J. Paul Boehmer (Neil)

Notes

add »
First appearances by Brian Klugman and Patricia Clarkson.
(edit)
Kirby's T-shirt says, "Chicks dig scrawny pale guys." (edit)
Jean Smart won her second straight Emmy, at the 2001 Emmy Awards, for Outstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy Series for her role as Lana Gardner in this and the next four episodes. (edit)
Jean Smart reprises her role as Lorna Lynley, only now she is called Lana Gardner for legal reasons. (edit)
This episode and "A Passing Fancy (2)" were put together to form an hour-long episode in the United States at the last minute, hence the two titles, two writers and two directors. It was felt the second episode did not stand on its own well enough, and that viewers needed to see the previous episode to understand what was going on. (edit)

Quotes

add »
Kirby: I don't have a pen. But just tell me, I'll remember it.
Lana: Oh yeah, yeah, that's gotten you far. (they look at her) GET OFF YOUR ASS AND GET A PEN!!!
(edit)
Frasier: Well, it's getting late.
Lana: It's 9:30! Let's face it, I drove them all off. Even I'm sick of hearing me complain about Bob.
(edit)
Daphne: Oh, well, um, mine's also a youthful indiscretion. I stole a teddy bear from the shops.
Roz: Then what?
Daphne: Well, I felt guilty, so I told my parents and we brought it back. Then as a penance, I... volunteered to work at the orphanage after school.
Roz: What the hell was that?! I'd put that story on my resume! Come on, Martin, you've got to have something! Shock me!
Martin: Oh, I don't know, it's kind of personal.
Roz: That's what we're looking for.
Martin: Well, all right, but it doesn't leave this room: every time I watch "The Sound of Music"... I cry. And I don't mean a single manly tear. I mean real blubbering, girl-style. The nuns... those kids... that lonely goatherd.
Roz: These are your deep, dark secrets? This is baby stuff! "Ooh, I dropped my ice cream and I ate it!"
(edit)
Niles: OK, I'll go first. Oh, let's see - all right, well, Daphne, you might as well make your acquaintance with my dark side. In fifth grade, there was a bully, Jack Winfield, who was bothering a lot of the girls, so one day I waited for him outside of school and gave him a sound thumping.
Martin: Wasn't that the kid with rickets?
Niles: Rickets and a smart mouth.
(edit)
Claire: Thanks for getting her here.
Frasier: Well...
Claire: How did you manage to keep it a secret?
Frasier: Well, as a psychiatrist, discretion happens to be the cornerstone of my profession.
Claire: Ah, of course. Mine too - I'm a family therapist.
(edit)

Trivia

add »
When Frasier is talking with Claire in the electronics store amidst the DVD organizers, a wedding band on his left hand disappears and reappears several times in between shots.
(edit)
Daphne refers to "a youthful indiscretion" wherein she stole a teddy bear from the shops. By the time her story is done, she comes off sounding more like a saint than a sinner. In Season Eleven's "High Holidays", however, we get an entirely different picture. She says that as a teenager she was into (among other things) shoplifting - to the extent that she can carry a frozen turkey between her knees.
(edit)
When Frasier mentions him, Claire says that she loves Kierkegaard. Søren Aabye Kierkegaard was a 19th century Danish philosopher and theologian, generally recognized as the first existentialist philosopher.
(edit)
Frasier did not speak German as of “An Affair to Forget”.
Perhaps he has learned since then, or that earlier episode was simply
inconsistent – since it is virtually required that any serious student
of Freud should read him in the original German. (edit)

Allusions

add »
The third scene title is "WHAT WOMEN MAY OR MAY NOT WANT". This alludes to the film What Woman Want which premiered December 2000.
(edit)
Title: Semi-Decent Proposal
The episode title is a reference to the 1993 Drama "Indecent Proposal". (edit)
Tell the world what you think of Semi-Decent Proposal (1), write a review for this episode.
Write a Review

Community Reviews (1)

 
10.0
Perfect
Semi-Decent Proposal (1)
"Another great installment"
Frasier meets a charming and attrative woman named Claire.
Continue » Posted May 21, 2007 1:30 pm PST
Previous Next
advertisement

Episode Vital Stats

 
Episode: Semi-Decent Proposal (1)
Season Number: 8
Episode Reviews: 1
Episode
Score:
9.0 Superb 31 votes
Rating Statistics:
great: 12 (38.7%)
superb: 12 (38.7%)
perfect: 5 (16.1%)
good: 2 (6.5%)
Your Semi-Decent Proposal (1) Score
This content requires Macromedia Flash Player 7 or higher. Get Flash
Review This Episode Contribute

Top Contributors

 
Retired jameshdl
Score: 2,531 points
Editor danbambridge
Score: 1,835 points
kgarrett
Score: 1,172 points
Retired DoctorShade
Score: 841 points
tt432l
Score: 311 points
RabbiRotes
Score: 292 points
francklloyd
Score: 140 points
millerem99
Score: 139 points
PikeBishop
Score: 125 points
dju010
Score: 108 points