Jack is unaware that the woman he slept with, Gia, is Pino's mistress, who lives above the restaurant. He goes into panic mode by trying to cover up his latest shenanigan but at the same time, Gia wants to tell Pino about their affair because Jack looks after her whereas Pino does not. Everything then goes awry when Pino throws his wife a party and his mistress arrives threatening to tell all.
Meanwhile, Steven, Teddy and Seth plan to take Jim out to get him laid but they instead use his pityful nature to pick up girls for themselves.