Did SNL Steal Its Celebrity Accountant Sketch?

By Brian Abrams

Apr 13, 2011

Illustrator Dan Meth has staked a claim that Saturday Night Live ripped off his online animated video series—and blatantly.

The New York-based artist, known for his internet-famous sitcom maps points out on his blog the similarities between his own Alan Kaufman, rock star accountant at Kaufman, Kaufman, Rothman, and Roth: Rock Star Financial (the cartoon first went live in 2007), and Andy Samberg's Mort Mort Feingold, Celebrity Accountant, who didn't hit the airwaves until April 2010.

You might find it difficult to argue otherwise for Samberg's character: Mort Mort Feingold is exactly the same nebbish caricature as Meth's Alan Kaufman—throwing obnoxious jabs at vapid celebrities. See for yourself:

Churning out the chuckles every week for national television isn't easy, so it's not such a surprise to hear that SNL would Xerox material from an artist with likely no loot for legal representation in order to grab some laughs. Stuff like this happens all the time. Last month, the Late Show with David Letterman aired a bit that mashed up clips of Charlie Sheen and Mel Gibson into a farcical phone conversation. One week prior, satirical Hollywood blog Film Drunk had posted the exact same concept. (Though, given how topical tiger blood has been of late, it's a little more difficult to point fingers as that one.)  

The Letterman bit could be chalked up as pure happenstance, but the SNL sketch, albeit having aired in the throes of tax season, seems beyond coincidence. Then again, Bill & Ted's Alex Winter featured a rock n' roll accountant bit on his MTV sketch comedy show, The Idiot Box, before Samberg was even born. (Skip to the 6:00 mark here.)

Do you think Lorne Michaels might throw Meth a bone or two by hiring to do some cartoon shorts as reparation? That's all the artist is asking for. 

  • Comments (5)
Add a Comment
In reply to :
  • antdude Apr 14, 2011

    Wow, those were lame.

  • lolamustang Apr 14, 2011

    it's not the first time snl has done so.

  • Writerpatrick Apr 13, 2011

    It is common for two different writers to come up with the same idea. But what might have happened in this case is that the SNL writer saw the material and forgot that he had, then would up reusing it. But an idea can be stolen legally as long as there's enough difference between the new material and the old. I do think we're going to see this happening more and more in the future. And ironically, if they steal an idea from a TV show or movie it would be considered a parody.

  • bluejayfusion Apr 13, 2011

    I guess that is sad. The SNL one was funny but they really shud give people credit instead of just lifting their material.

  • aaronmcc Apr 13, 2011

    It's really getting on my nerves that tv.com polluted their content with UK rubbish and then go and post stories like this where the videos cannot be viewed in the UK.