Legit's Series Premiere: Heart of Darkness

By Tim Surette

Jan 18, 2013

Legit S01E01: "Pilot"

If you had asked me to review JUST the pilot episode of FX's new comedy Legit immediately after watching it, it would probably look something like this:

"Australian comedian Jim Jefferies stars as a version of himself in this obvious attempt to replicate the unpolished heroism of Louie. But instead of the relatable, existential dilemmas that make Louie one of the most observant and personal series on television, Legit is a menagerie of masturbation jokes in a cloud of purple haze, with its value and emotion completely dependent on your opinion of Mumford & Sons' "The Cave," which provides the score for a road trip scene that's somehow supposed to help the episode mature."

Ugh thank the lord of pseudo-intellectualism that I don't actually write like that. Anyway, I initially watched the pilot out of genuine curiosity and with no work-strings attached about a month ago, dismissed it as boys' club potty humor, and switched over to some Archer DVDs. But in revisiting Legit this week to write a review, I recognize that I was either having a bad day the first time I watched it or I was dumb.

Legit is trying to be Louie in some sense, whether consciously or not. Jim is a moderately successful comedian who lives a life he can't seem to control, so he's trying to do something about it. The humor, which includes a tirade about the benefits of marrying a dying woman, is pitch black. And the set-up is free of the typical sitcom structure, proving that comedy doesn't have to always hit marks or include 10 jokes per page. But most importantly—and I didn't really get this in the pilot, but started to see it in the next two episodes—the show has good intentions behind its filthy exterior.

Of all of FX's comedies, Legit may be the one that takes the longest to warm up to (disclaimer: You should still be hypothermic when it comes to Anger Management, and that show should never come to mind when I speak of "FX comedies"). The pilot, which followed Jim as he took his friend's wheelchair-bound brother Billy (DJ Qualls) to lose his virginity at a Nevada house o' whores, was more concerned about hygienically preparing the crotch of a paralyzed man for swallowing by a hooker than it was with being charming. And I don't know when I became such a prude, but jokes about ball-washing just seem too easy and obvious.

It was during my second viewing of the pilot that I started to come around, and by the end, talk of Billy's sparkling balls and his Fassbender-ish shlong seemed worth enduring in order to stick with the show a little longer. In the second episode, that clemency paid off: Next week's installment tones down the raunch, and Jim and Billy have a long heartfelt talk that humanizes both of them and transforms the series from Porky's V into something more emotional. And it doesn't need Mumford & Sons to prop it up. The moment is vital because it gives the series a better platform to build on and the viewers something meaningful to look forward to. This is a show about becoming a better person, and that isn't going to happen after 30 minutes. It's only after an hour, and then an hour and a half, that the differences start to become noticeable.

If you like the dick jokes, great, you'll love the series. But if you were put off by the pilot, I'd highly recommend watching the next two episodes of Legit before quitting it completely. It finds its stride and its heart pretty quickly as the rough edges are sanded down to the merely prickly nubs you expect from Jefferies' style of humor. Legit won't be in the same echelon as Louie, but it has a chance to be great on its own.


– It will be interesting to see how this pairs with Archer as the two are, for the most part, tonally different.

– Steve (Dan Bakkedahl) doesn't have much to do except recite variants of, "Really, Jim?" as the uptight buddy. So far, he's in need of the most work.

– Ditto for Steve's mom.

– After Billy's euphoric fade to white, I thought the pilot ended on a good note. But then there was a bumper with Jim getting pulled over while his friends were all tuckered out. I see how it's important to show Jim some extra benefits of friendship, but Billy's happy face is where I think it should have ended.

– I like this show more and more with every minute watched.

Follow TV.com writer Tim Surette on Twitter: @TimAtTVDotCom

  • Comments (19)
Add a Comment
In reply to :
  • mknochel Feb 01, 2013

    This show is sooooo funny. every episode just gets better and better. DJ Qualls was a perfect choice for this show.

  • ben45tpy Jan 26, 2013

    This might be the most helpful review ever. I disliked the pilot but now I have some hope looking forward.

  • natesjokes Jan 21, 2013

    I'm a big fan of Jefferies and enjoyed the pilot of "Legit", unfortunately I've heard all the jokes & heard the entire brothel encounter via stand up, so it wasn't as enjoyable as I expected. Looking forward to seeing the next few episodes though.

  • youngnan Jan 19, 2013

    the ending up, where he's pulled over is the best part, along with the terminally ill mother of his child discourse

  • ted2332 Jan 19, 2013

    You had me at "Nevada house o' whores". :)

  • adamonfire Jan 18, 2013

    Jefferies is brilliant.

  • Pawtley Jan 18, 2013

    Thanks for the write-up, Tim; if I wasn't already aware of him, I think I might have had your initial reaction, too (and even then...).

    I am willing to give (new dad and husband, too, I think) Jefferies's show at least three eps. Does the character of Jim's own mum make an appearance beyond a phoner, I wonder.

  • Left4Ed Jan 18, 2013

    I found the whole setup of this episode much funnier, when Jim was telling it in his stand-up special, Alcoholocaust. Not to say it didn't have its moments, but the structure of 22 min. + commercials takes some of the shine off. Still, gotta give it the four episode test, since Jefferies is a hilarious comedian, if you like fucked up, perverted humor. And especially since DJ Qualls, no matter the quality of show, is always a quality actor. He, more than anyone, sold the show.

  • prowly Jan 18, 2013

    Wow, the Tim Stamp of Approval! I definitely need to check this show out!

  • darkitp Jan 18, 2013

    i have noticed alot of shows becoming more involved with the actor's real name but different personality like Matt LeBlanc in episodes , James Van Der Beek in Apartment 23 ..

    so i am starting to hate this repetitive idea .. but loving the originality of some shows ..
    Louie has truly succeeded in his show , others just suck ..

    i still have to watch other episodes of this show to decide to continue watching or dumping it
    what interested me in the show was D. J. Qualls
    the first episode reminds me a lot of a movie called Road Trip (2000) which had DJ Qualls in it too

    though i don't know if his character will be a regular or just guest starring .. which suck for the show because the main actor Jim Jefferies is a egotistic character , i didnt like him very much .. if the show will continue as the same level , it will be cancelled before they end airing all the episodes

  • See More Comments (6)