QUICK QUESTION: Which TV Shows Have the Best Special Effects?

By Price Peterson

Jun 21, 2012

That the new Golden Age of Television coincided with huge advancements in computer-generated effects can't be a coincidence, right? Sure, celebrated shows like The Wire and Deadwood were maaaybe better known for their writing than they were for CGI, but these days it's hard to find a classic show that doesn't somehow include seamless special effects. Most of the big genre hits have effects that rival or surpass those found in summer movies, but even dramas like Breaking Bad and Mad Men use computer imagery in such crucial ways that these shows may have been prohibitively expensive to produce in earlier eras. So let's give all those unheralded tech whizzes their props: Special effects have never been better or more crucial to the shows we love.

Below are some off-the-top-of-our-heads picks for TV shows with the best effects work. Which show's visuals are YOU constantly amazed by?



Falling Skies


Falling Skies is a great example of a show where viewers can debate the quality of the writing, but the special effects are unimpeachable. Seriously, they look expensive! Whether it's the nightmarish Skitters, the lumbering Mechs, or those tall skinny alien dudes (or are they ladies?), the effects alone are worth tuning in for.



The Walking Dead


Effects gurus Gregory Nicotero, Robert Kurtzman, and Howard Berger formed the KNB Efx Group in the late '80s but have steadily become the industry gold standard for horror effects. Their zombie work on The Walking Dead, a mixture of CGI and practical effects, holds the high honor of being probably the most disgusting imagery ever broadcast on cable. In this case that's a compliment!



Fringe


One can point to the various creatures of Fringe (human porcupines! Ribcage burrowers! Genetic hybrid abominations!) as examples of the show's top-notch effects work, but some of the most impressive CGI on the show is what you may not notice. Specifically all the split-screen work where characters must interact with their own doppelgangers on a regular basis. It's a deadly tricky thing to do and Fringe nails it every time.



Supernatural


Not to get nerdy about it, but Falling Skies only has three creatures to worry about. That's three CGI models already saved to a hard drive just waiting to be copied and pasted into new scenes. (I know more goes into it than that, but still.) A procedural like Supernatural has to deal with dozens of new creatures and scenarios all the time. It's frankly amazing how much Supernatural pulls off and how good it frequently looks despite its CW budget.



Doctor Who


Doctor Who seems to benefit greatly from its limited series format. The whole thing looks expensive probably because the average budget is more expensive than a show with 22-episodes a season. I've heard from people who enjoy the older doctors but prefer the Matt Smith series specifically for their production values. Looking at this trailer, it's pretty hard to disagree with that.



Game of Thrones


Game of Thrones is another show that uses effects in both ostentatious AND subtle ways. There's no debate about how straight-up incredible the wildfire incident was, but Season 2 also gave us Dany's haunting hallucination scene, plus the now-CGI direwolves looked just as organic and normal as their real dog predecessors. And those baby dragons looked so real that I'm pretty sure everyone in the world wants one now.



Spartacus


[VIDEO NSFW] A show that doesn't tend to do subtle well is Spartacus, but that's by design. Whether it's violence or sex or, you know, just scenery, everything has a heightened vibe to it. But where running every frame of footage through a computer might seem like a way to rob it of soul, Spartacus uses its CGI to pack almost every moment with emotion, horror, and splendor all at once.



Lost


It can be hard to get a conversation going about Lost these days, that's how still-controversial its ending was. But let's not forget what a fabulously beautiful show it was and how excellent its special effects were. From the black smoke monster to the plane crash to all the subtle scenery-related CGI seeded throughout each episode, Lost was epic in a way we may never see again.



Battlestar Galactica


It's pretty ironic that the cable network most notorious for its awful special effects pulled off this stunner: Syfy's Battlestar Galactica reboot contained some of the best effects ever seen on TV. From its newer, sleeker Cylons to those handheld-camera space battles, the style and quality of BSG's effects were not just great for its time, but have had an obvious influence on many of the sci-fi effects we're seeing in movies these days (Battleship's shaky battle footage being a recent example).



Ringer


Perhaps no show will ever be able to top the stunning special effects work of Ringer. Sorry, all other shows! Ringer nailed it.


YOUR TURN! Which TV shows do YOU think have the best special effects?

  • Comments (157)
Add a Comment
In reply to :
  • zoltanfeher31 May 13, 2013

    Obviously Primeval (especially Ep 1.6). No one has done that much and that good CGI as them in a dramatic series. Of course it has its downfalls sometimes, but still better than Terra Nova and the others. Doctor Who?? Come on, you're joking, right? I have to say it, the CGI in DW is a big pile of shit! I cannot understand why DW is so successful. The editing and acting is brilliant, but the story is horrible and those robots are so cheap. Btw, Primeval is the winner especially because the amount of CGI in an episode, which is still brilliant.

  • Tristan66 Jul 15, 2012

    Once Upon A Time, Game of Thones, Fringe, Firefly

  • Oziez Jun 26, 2012

    omg wow! you forgot sanctuary! lol, between the amazing Hollow Earth and it's creatures and landscape, to the dragons and giant insect creatures and monsters, never have i seen a show look so real and have so much air time with the creatures, i don't think any show has what it takes to compete with sanctuary where effects are concerned

  • Swinglabacase Jun 26, 2012

    Totally agree.

  • dh4645 Jun 26, 2012

    fringe, supernatural, doctor who and BSG.

  • GabrielLoki Jun 29, 2012

    Those are my choices too, except I would put Supernatural first. The stuff they pull off with a small budget is just amazing! It really is "the little show that could" in so many ways.

  • GhostKiller Jun 25, 2012

    Game of Thrones, Blackwater was AMAZING.

    Supernatural, quite good.

    Doctor Who, good seeing the budget.

    Ringer, AWESOME!

  • GhostKiller Jun 25, 2012

    This guy.

  • mancnbhoy Jun 25, 2012

    The effects on BSG were so good they didn't feel like effects. The whole universe felt real. The writers did a great job too, in creating their own vernacular. It didn't take long before you just felt part of the whole and could concentrate on the story, and the scripts rarely let us down.



    One of the best SciFi programmes of all time. Nothing has come close since.

  • mindmalfunction Jun 25, 2012

    The Walking Dead!!!!

  • C3rn0baL Jun 25, 2012

    And the winner is.. BSG! Hello, BSG had the best CGI on TV that I've ever seen. No other show since has demonstrated that level of stunning CGI. I swear every episode felt like a movie. And I'm not easily impressed. First place definitely goes to BSG.



    The rest..meh! Kinda see it like this:

    Runner up - Supernatural. It's quite good for a TV show, considering the budget as well.

    3rd place - Game of Thrones. I'm not much of a fantasy buff but I have to say the CGI looks quite good. Did expect more though. I mean it's HBO for crying out loud.



    The rest I don't really have an opinion about. I like Fringe, but definitely not for the FX.

  • mermayd Jun 25, 2012

    I don't understand - is Ringer in as a joke. That looks like the producers of Gilligan's Island have made a come back. She's clearly in a studio not going anywhere. Stupid



    I would vote for BSG and Supernatural. The British show Spooks (spy thriller) used to have pretty good effects on a shoestring budget. They used to blow things up all over the place. Fabulous.



    The Pilot of Lost was sensational stuff.

  • Swinglabacase Jun 25, 2012

    LoL! Yes, Ringer is in as a joke...

  • See More Comments (112)