This vs. That: Falling Skies or Defiance?

By Jen Trolio

Jun 20, 2013

Welcome to the latest round of TV.com's "This vs. That," where we pit two things against one another and you vote on which one should win... in whatever context you choose. I think we can all agree that this particular match-up is simply otherworldly... because ALIENS! Yes, with Defiance winding down its first season and Falling Skies still in the early stages of its third, there's all kinds of ETs on TV right now (even if some of them are decidedly more civil-seeming than others). So tell me, won't you please...

poll


Feel free to show your work in the comments!

PREVIOUSLY: This vs. That: True Blood or Teen Wolf?

Ed. note: Eventually we really do hope to make good on our initial promise of "new match-ups every few days." If there's a specific battle you'd like to see, send it via PM to TVcom_editorial, via Twitter to @tvdotcom, or via email to mailbag@tv.com. (And thanks to those of you who've already submitted ideas!)

  • Comments (221)
Add a Comment
In reply to :
  • sukemadiq Aug 06, 2013

    Defiance wins by hot Lesbian Alien action!

  • matheny Jul 22, 2013

    This is a very tough matchup. After reading many of the comments, I still have to call it a draw. Both shows are filled with promise and highly inconsistent.

  • hockeyrick Jul 06, 2013

    D is cooler and has a killer soundtrack!!!!!!
    FS is just kinda dumb at most times but still better than most!

  • MatthewRaiche Jul 03, 2013

    OK, the whole "they copied (...)" is really starting to get annoying. Who cares? There hasn't been a completely original alien invasion story since Jules Verne wrote "War of the Worlds" in the late 19th century. The last totally original "humans vs. some other intelligent beings" was the Chtulu Mythos by H.P. Lovecraft in the early 20th century.

    Nearly every popular band out there has used Pachelbel's Canon in D and the 1-4-5 progression ("Knockin' on Heaven's Door," "Keep on Rockin' in the Free World," etc...) at least once. So stop complaining about unoriginality. With nearly 10,000 years of art in some form or another behind is, it's kind of difficult to be 100 percent original.

  • gregblindman Aug 04, 2013

    Correction. H.G. Wells wrote "War of the Worlds" not Verne.

  • MatthewRaiche Aug 08, 2013

    Oh, yeah. Oops.

  • jelex1978 Jun 29, 2013

    If we want real SyFy then just bring back the Stargate series. Make a proper ending to Stargate Universe. Best Syfy series of the last 15 years. People are still buying the dvd's and watching the re-runs. As there is no proper syfy out there at the moment.

  • Melbot Jul 08, 2013

    Woooooooo! Stargate!!!!! I miss the franchise, they should have given Universe a better chance.

  • MikeUK123 Jun 27, 2013

    Now I've seen a few episodes of Falling Skies..... It has it's issues, but it is much better written and has a much more believable story and characters.

    Defiance just wants to be a soap opera, pulling in an extra sci-fi audience by dressing up and putting make-up on a few crazy characters.

    Falling Skies, with it's issues, highlights just how bad Defiance really is.

  • Denun1 Jun 25, 2013

    You can't really compare those shows, i mean yes are both scifi shows but one (falling skies) is more oriented for mature people (25+) while defiance can be more enjoyable for younger audience.
    by the way i hope both shows will run for years.

  • usedcat Jun 25, 2013

    In This case BOTH !!!

  • nutleygrundt Jun 25, 2013

    I will side with defiance, I like the fractured misunderstood nobility of the spirit riders, and ANY tv show the orchestrates a scene with Van Morrison's "into The Mystic" is amazing in my book.... More Spirit Riders, Less GUNS..... HOW much violence in the real world? who needs to see, it sanctioned on a show that is ostensibly about learning how to live post conflict? script rwriters.... give the daughter the ball, and let her run with it!

  • dif_frent Jun 24, 2013

    You can't really compare "Falling Skies" to "Defiance". The first is a family show (at least it was such when I stopped watching it well into season 1), and the latter is for 18-year-olds-plus. You won't be watching the sex scenes with you children, will you? Of course, there is some atmosphere of a family show in "Defiance " too, and that is quite disturbing to me. Hope the script writers will remove that "family" aura from season 2 (if they planned to have it again), and make "Defiance" a full-blooded sci-fi thriller.

  • See More Comments (95)