Pilot

Episode Reviews (6)

Great
75 votes
8.3
  • SORT BY:
  • 9.8

    Good episode

    By tenn99_23, Mar 28, 2008

    Elizabeth is defending Ethan Foster, who has been accused breaking into Scott and Helen Jasper's house and kidnapping and then killing their son. First, the state needs to prove it. Elizabeth is certain that Scott has abused his son because of all of the old injuries, but she can't prove it. Ethan confessed to the crime, but later recanted because he was not given his medication during the time. All hope was lost until Elizabeth cooked up a plan to get Ethan to say he was in the woods that night and saw Scott hit his son. The prosecution had no choice but to call Scott to the stand, which was Elizabeth's hope all along. Once Scott was on the stand, Elizabeth asked him about the alarm system and why the code was just changed on it. Scott said that they changed it every couple of months. Elizabeth showed him the report from the alarm company stating that the circuitry had been tampered with. She then asked Scott what his son got top prize in a science project for. He couldn't remember until Elizabeth read him an article from the paper say it was for electricity and circuitry. She then accused him of hitting him once he tried to sneak out of the house again. He denied it, but she kept on...that is until Scott punched her in the face in front of everyone. She rested her case right after that, having proved that Scott was violent. Later, Elizabeth is in her office later icing down her face and proclaimed that she would do whatever it took to prove her client's innocence.moreless

    0 0

  • 8.5

    I love Julianna but the jury is still out on the show.

    By mccar29, Mar 14, 2008

    I have missed Julianna ever since she left ER,so it's great to see her back in a series. This series is another crime drama. However, it's from the prespective of the defense attorney, not like the majority of the shows out there right now that are prosecution based. I found the lead character, Liz Canterbury to be very engaging. She's tough but comes across as being very human. In this first episode, she vigorously defends a young man accused of kidnapping and killing a little boy. We find out at the end of the episode that her own little son was kidnapped while in her care. She is very confident and pushes everyone to get her way. However, she's also soft and vunerable. When she climbed into her son's bed and smelled his pillow, I couldn't stop the tears. This show has great potential. However, my biggest worry is the pro defendant angle. Cop bashing, victim bashing or prosecuter bashing would be a big turn off for me.moreless

    1 0

  • 8.6

    Julianna Margulies makes that show sparkle..

    By Parricida, Mar 13, 2008

    I have never watched that kind of court serie before.. and the reason I even had interest to that serie was that when I heard that Julianna Margulies will be on the leading role - I thought, I have to see it. And there was no disappointment. She once again proves that when it comes from acting, playing complex chars and bringing up the emotion, she has it all. The way she likes on magic has that kind of passion to make people go with her.. feel for her char... it is fantastic.



    On everything else, than her performance. As I have never seen tv shows like that, so it was all new for me, and quite fascinated me, I most say. But what I do know , I would ask.. And I do not know..but I like when there is emotion, when there is something to sympathize for, unexpected things happening, hopeless situation what to overcome - all that was there. So, I most say, I pretty much liked it.moreless

    1 0

  • 5.0

    Not a good start for a new series.

    By bonkerguy, Mar 11, 2008

    Now, I will admit to knowing next to nothing about this before seeing the previews earlier in the day.



    And I have to say, not a good start for the new series. I found the shows main characters completely uninteresting, and in some cases, rather unlikeable. The interaction between the shows leads was a little hard accept at times.... case in point... during one scene the lead is yelling at an underling that he had betrayed her and sunk the case, fast forward and now the lead is telling her husband that she trusts said underling completely!!! The pilot story seemed fairly rushed as if they were trying to jam too much of the backstory in. By the end of the show I found that I could care less on the outcome of the trial.



    I may give it another go just to be fair, we'll see how charitable I'm feeling next week.moreless

    0 1

  • 6.0

    I'm underwhelmed.

    By ebbydmp, Mar 11, 2008

    I was semi excited to see the show from watching the commercials and from hearing somewhere that Canterbury was supposed to be kinda like House, but I was going to wait 'til I actually saw the show before I got my hopes all high. When the show came on I stopped the work I was doing and was waiting to be wowed, but it never came. First I was unimpressed that she was sleepig with a man who wasn't her husband, and even more so that he was a client of hers. All I could think was that she was violating some sort ethics law. Then she had some interaction with the people in her office that I found boring and tuned out after a minute. Then she had some interactions with the judge that should have been good, but alas they were not. When she was in court she made some jokes I guess I was supposed to laugh at, but didn't. The only thing that saved the episode, and kept me from giving it a 3, was the way she got the father to confess. It was brilliant, but poorly played out becasue I felt like they did it half way instead of going at it full force. Then in the end comes a shocker... her son was kidnapped and that's why she worked so hard to get this kid's real killer put in jail. I never saw that coming. Anyhow, I'm giving this show one more episode to entertain me before I write it off comepletely.moreless

    1 0