Episode Reviews (7)

247 votes
  • SORT BY:
  • 6.5

    I have to be perfectly honest here and I hate to smash the show, but that episode was absolutely terrible, what the heck were they thinking? The only good thing was JJ...she looked hot as hell...02/10/09 looks good tho.

    By ChristianLeavit, Dec 05, 2011

    Well since I have to write at least 100 words here, I will use this opportunity to once again slam this episode and share my thoughts on what direction the show should go in. The acting in this episode was horrendous, that is the same guy that use to play in Days of Our Lives when he use to see Kate...hahaha. He was terrible on that show to. As I said above, JJ looks absolutely stunning. She should def be given more of a role in the show. She has the personality and the look. They could make her a star. One last thing, I get the feeling that the show maybe running out of creative ideas. I know this sounds crazy, but what if one of the characters was to have a secret life? Plotting and planning something big? Maybe one of the characters becomes a victim? Start creating more sub plots, exciting ones. Maybe one of the characters suffers a serious stressor and sends them spiraling out of control into a crazy rage. They could play this out over time and would generate crazy ratings if its done properly. I dunno, I like to ramble, but maybe someone else out there feels the same way?moreless

    2 9

  • 5.5

    Are you sure this was a Criminal Minds episode?! Certainly didn't feel like it.

    By gamerb83, Dec 05, 2011

    I really wanted to like this episode, I really did. But the longer I watched, the harder it became to fool myself. This episode didn't feel like a Criminal Minds episode to me. It was very blah and boring. Nothing really kept my interest. In fact, I spent most of the ep playing UNO on FaceBook. It wasn't that the case was boring. The premise was interesting in and of itself. But it was very poorly executed, and I think that's why it fell short and failed to keep my attention. I doubt I'll be re-watching this episode any time soon.moreless

    1 4

  • 9.5

    Surprised people have marked this down so low. I've just started to catch up with the series, which I fell out of faith with end of last year - largely due to the writers' obsession with one of the character. This is much much better, IMO

    By eggyface, Oct 09, 2011

    Love the actor who played the white collar cop. Now THAT is a good actor. Who is he? He got inside the role, didn't he? And he stands out head and shoulders above cut outs such as Gibson. This was a good plot, nice tension, and beautifully acted by a serious actor and there was -- blessed relief -- none of that over-sentimental flaccid stuff we were given the first half of this season. The con guy and his family were OK but the detective made it. Him and Mantegna. Similar weight and energy in their styles.

    It's an interesting premiss for the unsub. The underlying narcissism and whatever else made up his 'dark triangle' condition, but put under pressure by his high-stress job and the economy. You kept thinking the kid might save him. A simple identity: not Hunter or Grant or Randy but 'Dad'.

    But really it was the desk cop's personality and vague intensity that made the main interest. There was one beautifully filmed moment, the angles and the attention on the plane where the cop looks out the jet window watched by Rossi. Subtle. More human relation and depth in that one moment than in most of what we were served up through the long Hotchner arc.

    BRAVO the writer and the director, whoever you are, and particularly white-collar cop guy, whoever you are. Good on you. Ah... it was Oanh Ly. No wonder it was so good.moreless

    3 5

  • 10

    A pretty interesting episode, and I enjoyed the storyline.,

    By amazing_race, Feb 28, 2011

    This was a very interesting episode of Criminal Minds, although it was a rather unusual and different one, which to me, is usually a great thing.

    I thought the case was highly interesting, mainly because it was set out so differently to most other episodes. The killer in this episode wasn't some soulless animal, as we usually have, and this really provided us with so many different views into the show.

    OI did think that the episode focussed too little on the actual team, and we hardly saw most characters. That was disappointing for me, but the case was quite good.

    It was a very touching case, with a very sad ending, and I would hjighly recommend watching this one, as it is so different!moreless

    5 0

  • 7.0

    Far from my favourite episode.

    By bellagirl_008, Jun 05, 2010

    this, week we were lacking good gripping story, and i feel that if were lacking good story we should at least have some good character bonding/development, but this episode had none of the above, while i found the murderess con man billy an intresting charater he alone was not enough to carry the story.

    Good points: this episode had a new criminal which we haven't seen before, loved the wife and the girlfriend meeting up thought that was great, the faces of the team when they saw all the paper work were great, and finally morgan complaining about paper work and reid saying he finds it relaxing(the only little team scene in the whole episode).

    Overall not a great episode but seing it follows several great and though provoking episodes i'll let this one slide.


    6 2

  • 8.8

    Good and though-provoking storytelling

    By Parricida, Feb 04, 2010

    That was interesting episode. I mean, it was somehow different.. maybe the way they got into the case but it was brilliantly build. I thought the beginning was little slow but the ending really made me treasure the whole episode. We just needed to start far to get to the point we were in the end and this way it had huge impact.. I loved the concept: the man gets confused who he is because of all those aliases and he falls apart and the way his actions.. To have a family put have no trouble of killing and playing everyone... that look on the wife's face when she realizes it.. And that poor boy.. Great story telling.moreless

    4 3