A Simple Twist of Fate

Episode Reviews (7)

Great
102 votes
8.8
  • SORT BY:
  • 9.0

    Amazing Acting, Nice Character Development

    By captainboots, May 27, 2014

    Excellent acting in this episode. The best actors and characters were highlighted and the drama was more real and less contrived than some other episodes this season. I feel terribly for the Greene family and hope everything works out... Abby is a badass and it sucks to see her vulnerable but I love that Luka is still watching her back.

    0 0

  • 9.5

    Luka delivers a beat down

    By Tawny246, Aug 22, 2013

    I don't support violence but Brian deserved the beat down he got from Luka for hurting Abby. It showed yet again that Luka would do anything to protect Abby. I watched that bar scene over twice just to see the calm yet lethal way Luka sent his message to Brian. The episode in my opinion was the best of the season and this season was great. All that Mark and Elizabeth are going through plus what will happen later is highlighted significantly in this episode. Plus the additionally humour with some of the staff getting food poison was classic! lol :)moreless

    1 0

  • 9.3

    Never under estimate mad and angry people

    By Parricida, Jan 11, 2008

    The aftermath of last episode continues as Elizabeth is totally out of herself and feels that Mark is not acting properly. She ends up asking Rachel to leave and she is ok even if Mark is not. And she says - if Rachel goes or she goes.



    To make Mark's day even worser - he has doubts that his cancer is back. And that is frightening. And to be honest, Mark is not only one having hard day. Abby tries to help her neighbor. That sweet Joyce and she is beaten up again. She involves police and Joyce is taken to shelter. The husband goes to Abby place and beats her up rising anger in Luka who goes and beats up the husband. This time, I hope, Luka's anger did not kill anyone, at leastmoreless

    0 0

  • 9.4

    The ultimate bad day for Mark and Abby.

    By OpalRisa, Oct 07, 2006

    For Mark Greene, his infant daughter is still fighting to recover from a drug overdose after swallowing Rachel's Ecstacy pills. Elizabeth tells Rachel to get out of her house, leaving Mark caught between his wife and his teenaged daughter. His attempts at bridging the gap between the two women in his life only further anger Elizabeth. She gives Mark an ultimatum....get Rachel out of the house or she will leave him and take Ella with her. To make matters worse, Mark's symptoms return, and the episode ends with Mark undergoing another MRI to determine whether his brain tumor has returned.



    For Abby, her efforts at helping her neighbor, Joyce, take a dramatic turn. After Brian beats Joyce, Abby and Luka treat her at the ER. Abby convinces her to leave Brian and go into a battered women's shelter. Later that night, Brian shows up at Abby's apartment, demanding to know where Joyce is. Abby kicks him out, but he breaks down the door and punches her, knocking her out. We see Abby as the patient, as Susan and Luka treat her. Luka finds Brian at a bar and beats him. He threatens to kill Brian if he comes near Abby again.



    The thing that struck me in this episode is that two of the strongest characters on ER...Mark and Abby...were the vulnerable ones. They were both trying to be mediators in difficult situations, which left them both vulnerable, wounded and exposed.moreless

    2 0

  • 9.6

    Ella is find, Rachel isn't.

    By kimmie_chan, Sep 28, 2006

    I like this episode, it was very good. Very emotional for DR. Greene, having to choose over his 2 daughters and his wive. I really like to know what he is going to choose?.



    And then is Abby, who is trying to save Joyce and end up beaten by the guy, i just love how Luka go to the bar and fight with the guy and then told him that if he ever touch abby againe he is going to kill him!, omg that was so cool. I tought Kerry wwould be seen more at this episode but not, only in the first part, it would have been soo cool that at the end she would said something like: "i told you" (about the free food)moreless

    0 0

  • 9.5

    Typical day at the ER until Abby gets between her abusive neighbor and his wife and ends up as a patient herself.

    By atoz329, Jan 20, 2006

    I have probably seen this episode 10 times and every time, I remember why it is one of my favorites. Although the episode is action-packed, my favorite plotline is Abby and her neighbor- The doctor/nurse-becoming-patient plot is one that ER has used a couple of times (Mark Greene's cancer, Carter & Lucy's stabbing, Greene's beating, Carter's addiction...) and it works every time. We see that brave, independent Abby is vulnerable and powerless in this situation, but almost more importantly is how compassionate the rest of the ER staff is. Luka's expression when Susan mentions the possibility of rape says it all- any past history is insignificant in the face of trauma.moreless

    1 0