Hit Me Baby One More Time

Show Reviews (11)

109 votes
  • SORT BY:
  • 7.0

    A chance to reminisce with ex music superstars provides the perfect summer concoction.

    By jekyll, Nov 26, 2011

    Hit Me Baby One More Time takes us all on a time warp to visit stars of the past. A hit from the past, a little history of the performers, a catch-up interview, and a cover of a recent hit add up to a pleasant way to spend an hour.

    The show is not groundbreaking, or by any means spectacular, but packages music nostalgia in a likable format. Taking musical acts past their prime, generally at least a decade removed from their hit(s), the show gives them two chances to win over the audience for a $20,000 donation to a charity. The first half-hour sees all 5 acts get introduced via a montage of their past greatness, followed by them singing a hit song (sometimes their only hit) from their heyday. The second half sees each band in a short video updating what they're up to today. They then cover a recent hit song, to see if they can transcend their past glory and give spice to a song that's not their own. The audience then votes for their favorite with the winner earning the donation for a charity of their choosing. Transplanted from the original British version, host Vernon Kay keeps things moving, and mostly manages to avoid being irritating.

    The cover portion often generates some eyebrow raising performances, as seeing the now 50-something Wang Chung sing Nelly's "Hot in Herre" was mildly disturbing, even if they did do a good job of it. And to people who really only want to hear the good old hits, the second half can be utterly dispensible, making it the show's weak link. The show would finish stronger with the nostalgic hits sung last, though then it would start with a whimper, so it's a bit of a toss up. If they could get acts with two hits and make it 90 minutes, with the covers sandwiched by the past hits, it might work better.

    Either way, the chance to see people who've long left heavy rotation on the radio waves is a treat. While it would likely fare poorly against true competition, during a period of heavy reruns it's the ultimate summer concoction!moreless

    1 0

  • 8.0

    This show wasn't all that bad. It had some decent bands in it but it seemed like the worst performers would win all the time.

    By stardriven06, Jul 04, 2006

    I actually thought this show was good at times. I'm a fan of the 80's bands so it was interesting seeing them up there and then singing another band's song. It was kind of annoying though that they went through all the bands and their songs and then went through them again so they could sing another bands songs. I think when it started they had better bands like the first 3 episodes or so but that's obviously because they had to draw in a good crowd. Isn't this show popular in the UK or something? I remember hearing that they got the idea from them.moreless

    0 0

  • 4.3

    This was actually a promising concept...

    By dashm, Nov 12, 2005

    This was actually a promising concept, with one-hit wonders (such as the now not-as-hot Tiffany and now neither lovely nor boyish Loverboy) playing their hit, then covering a \"current\" hit. And seeing oldies on stage was actually kind of fun. They brought in a huge crowd to cheer for every song, which kind of doesn\'t make sense, because how could ANYONE be a HUGE fan of Loverboy, Tiffany, Arrested Development, and Flock of Seagulls (plus whatever her name who sang \"Finally\")? And just as fake was the show\'s host\'s British accent. ugh.

    Still, the show wasn\'t actually embarassing to the bands, except that each song was clipped at 2 minutes. We don\'t need no stinkin\' bridges! My real problem was that I didn\'t like any of the songs they were covering--all OLD (the newest came out at least 13 months ago) stuff by the likes of Faith Hill, Enrique Iglesias, Kelly Clarkson, and Los Lonely Boys.

    so I turned it offmoreless

    0 0

  • 7.7

    "Hit Me Baby One More Time" artists trying to get their groove back

    By gabriel927, Aug 13, 2005

    It's not the most popular TV show for younger audiences. However, it's not that bad either. I love the concept of the original artists who come back to stage their comebacks and win back old fans and introduce a younger generation to the history of greatest hits. At the end of the show, the live studio audience votes for their favorite artist(s). Whoever has the most votes wins money to donate to their favorite charities. It's an interesting concept, but I think the show needs to involve the TV viewers into the voting polls as well. If that gets incorporated well, the show can be just as good as or better than "American Idol."moreless

    0 0

  • 7.3

    I watched this show primarily for my husband. but I have to say that I kind of like it.

    By Melfank, Jul 03, 2005

    I watched this show primarily for my husband. but I have to say that I kind of like it. I enjoy listening to music in my car, and even then "live" is my least favorite type of music. However when I am home I like to watch something with a plot, not watch people sing, to me singing is something you listen to not watch.

    So when this came on and I actually enjoyed it, especially sense it is live music, I was shocked. I don't like American Idol, but I have to say that I like this show. I enjoy hearing songs that take me back, most of the bands were big when I was in high school. I also like seeing where people are today. I also like the fact that they play my favorite songs from way back when and then play my favorite songs from today. My husband is the one that Tivos it but I have to say that I have watched every episode before he has.moreless

    0 0

  • 3.0

    Why oh why do I torture myself so???

    By dbledutchs, Jun 23, 2005

    Okay, did anyone notice that the band (I can't remember their name for the life of me) who on their "second song" did 1985, messed up the lyrics? They said "Springstein, Madonna CRAZY FOR NIRVANA"....it's WAY BEFORE NIRVANA...that bothered me so much.

    And they guy...oh god, his name escapes me now, he played the piano, and sang that song, "I won't go down with this ship, I won't put my hands up and surrender"....anyhow, that was amazing, the best version I've heard of that song, besides the original.

    And does it bother anyone that Sophie B. Hawkins, was all like, " I get my inspiration for songs from painting...."...well, your one and only hit was a REMAKE of a Bob Dylan song....and he did it much better!! Cut the crap, you get your supposed inspiration from other people's talent!!

    I feel much better now.

    Great to see all of the old stuff though.


    1 1

  • 8.5

    One of the ultimate "Where are they now?" show.

    By The_Sweeper, Jun 16, 2005

    I laughed out loud when I first heard about this show. Now, being a fan of 80's music, I had to watch. Time hasn't been kind to most of them. But for those people who like the "hot" artists of today, beware......They could be on a show like this in 25 years! Word to your mother!

    1 0

  • 8.7

    Is Britney Spears getting mad at the title?

    By NBAlien, Jun 08, 2005

    One-hit wonder bands on NBC? Why did the prez put the show on the schedule? Anyway, it did had bands performing their only hits and their take on current hits, and the audience votes to their favorite band. It gives new meaning to the term: Groovy! Catch it every Thursday at 8 on NBC.

    0 0

  • 7.0

    Now you know why they only had one hit!

    By BallGame, Jun 04, 2005

    I enjoyed this show. It was fun to see that Flock of Seagulls was fat and totally lost his voice. He was so bad! Tiffany got a huge round of applause, but then was just ok. Arrested Development sounded the same and ended up winning the evening's competition. They really were head and shoulders above the rest.

    Gotta wait and see how the rest of the shows go, but I added it to my Season Pass collection on my TIVo.

    0 0

Load More Reviews