Jonathan Creek

Show Reviews (8)

Great
251 votes
8.6
  • SORT BY:
  • 10

    When it comes to mysteries, this show had the right stuff.

    By Maisy13, Apr 18, 2011

    I stumbled onto this show a few years ago and have been hooked ever since. I love how Jonathan reluctantly goes into a case, and still ends of solving it without breaking a sweat. With a few exceptions of course. I miss it terribly. It was well written, and had good characters. I was always curious as to why Maddy left, but I have to admit that I liked the addition of Carla to the show. I would have liked to see Maddy come back, and for her and Carla to face off for Jonathan's affections. I'm probably alone in this desire though. All in All, I loved the show, and I wish they would bring it back.moreless

    1 0

  • 9.7

    The best of British crime detection with a quirky twist - the wonderful Jonathan Creek himself and Alan Davies at his most eccentric! A good old fashioned murder mystery!

    By pinklavender, Sep 10, 2010

    The first three series of Jonathan Creek follows the story of Madeline Magellan who is an investigative journalist and who has a penchant for sticking her nose in where it isn't wanted! Of course she would say that this is what makes her such a great journalist! In the very first episode Maddy comes across Jonathan Creek whilst she is writing a piece about the death of a prominent artist (Hedley Shale).



    At the time, Jonathan is making his living in an ideal profession, designing illusions for an American, arrogant and clueless magician called Adam Klaus. It is Jonathan that has a brilliantly lateral mind and finds the answer to the even the most difficult of clues within hours! As can be seen in the episode No Trace of Tracy, he is at his most useful when he is playing logic games.



    Although Jonathan is quite a quiet man, he won’t let anyone take him for granted – particularly Maddy, which makes the chemistry between them interesting to say the least! He might not be the best looking but he is definitely cute and women find him extremely attractive – including Maddy – with whom he tries to form a relationship but it just doesn’t turn out as they had both hoped! His one failing perhaps is that he allows arrogant Adam to take the credit for his illusions! It is true he likes to take a back seat to limelight but thankfully Maddy does the right thing and mentions him in her work! Jonathan considers his work for Adam as being on the same par as a “bank commercial”! Actually this is quite ironic because Alan Davies made many commercials for television for a well-known Building Society!



    Deep down, Jonathan is a kind person who likes to see people smile when he makes his jokes; but he hates the inevitable public failing … that as soon as people know he “does magic tricks” they will expect to see him do one … like Maddy did on their first lunch date together!



    There is no doubt that Jonathan Creek is extremely charming and part of his charm is that he lives in a wonderful windmill, which is in the middle of nowhere (although near a railway station!) and is seen on a regular basis – including hilariously when a giant dummy revolves around it … and … even on one occasion when Jonathan walks across his bedroom completely starkers!



    Of course actress Caroline Quentin went on to different things … and all good things have to come to an end! But then up popped Carla, with whom he did start a relationship, but because of a misunderstanding … he hiccupped and Carla mis-heard what Jonathan said about her father … Carla went off and married someone else!!! Of course Carla realized the errors of her ways … but it is too late for them because Jonathan is too good natured and decent to have an affair with a married woman! Unlike Adam of course who would have anything if it had a pulse!



    It was a great shame when the series ended so suddenly. Alan Davies had done a brilliant job as JC. His transition from stand-up comedian to actor is outstanding! The best thing about the series is that everything worked well; it quickly became a very comfortable to watch every week. Personally I got withdrawal symptoms when it wasn’t on! Ridiculous really! But of course I like to be entertained … and Jonathan Creek was the best entertainment you could wish for!



    I think it is time it came back … don’t you??moreless

    7 0

  • 9.6

    The show follows Jonathan Creek, specialising in conjuring magic tricks who using his skills to solve some of the most baffling cases unsolved by anyone else.

    By bencoleman, Sep 10, 2010

    In my opinion if there was a word to describe this show it would be genius. The storylines are fantastic, the characters are lovable and even though it may seem silly every now and then it is pulled off very well. The episodes will keep you interested from the opening moments to the solving of the crime which are cleverly thought up and well disguised to throw you off to think something completely different. If you want a show that will excite you but also make you think and question but also scare you slightly, this is definately the show for you. Absolutely amazing.moreless

    1 0

  • 9.5

    An excellent and brilliantly cerebral show.

    By drdan2410, Sep 10, 2010

    The premise for this show is on the surface your standard murder mystery however the thing that sets it apart is the manner in which the crimes are commited. Essential the show is about Jonathan Creek a rather strange man who lives in a windmill and designs magic tricks for a living. From time to time he is called upon by an investigative journalist friend to help her investigate strange or impossible crimes using his lateral thinking mind.



    The show is fantastically writen with some very clever if overly elaborate plotlines. It is also superbly cast with Alan Davies as the title character.



    All in all this is a fantastic show and well worth a watch... just don't spend too long trying to figure out how it was done.moreless

    1 0

  • 10

    Jonathan Creek is definately one of the best television shows I have ever had the pleasure to watch.

    By mydevouredworld, Apr 09, 2006

    The classic mix of comedy, drama and mystery is what makes Jonathan Creek such a success in so many viewers eyes.

    Each and every season of this truely addictive English creation is jam packed with laughs and murder mystery to make you laugh.

    Each episode of Jonathan Creek entails some kind of mystery, usually murder, which the clever Jonathan manages to solve by the end of the show.

    Many a time will you find yourself watching Jonathan stare into space as all the pieces seem to come together in his mind, only to be left hanging for a result until the very end.

    Well know actors, comedian Alan Davies, Caroline Quentine, Anthony Head and Julia Sawalha, are the icing on the story-line cake.

    Amazing television. Jonathan Creek is the obvious choice next time you switch on the TV.moreless

    4 0

  • 5.4

    Classic of (unintentionally) absurd English crime-writing

    By mickjames, Oct 11, 2005

    The conceit of this series--a professional magician solves "impossible" cases--is quite neat, the only problem being the cases are often still impossible at the end of the show--at least as Creek explains them.



    Just to give one example, in one "locked room" mystery a man walls himself up behind a brick wall--and then somehow manages to beautifully point the brickwork on the other side. In many episodes the motivation for murder is so slight you wonder why the perpetrators bother. It's no wonder the police give up with a shrug and stand back while Creek wanders all over their crime scene, discovering "clues" at the rate of one a minute.



    It's clear that they know what we can only dimly surmise. Creek is the murderer, but his magician's sleight of hand means they can't got any hard evidence. So they give him his head and hope he gets too arrogant and slips up. Dozens of corpses later, this strategy shows no sign of working...







    moreless

    0 4

  • 9.6

    Unique drama series which will go down with the classics

    By Wezzo2005, Jul 29, 2005

    Jonathan Creek is an outstanding, unique show. It combines dark, macabre tales with humourous secondary stories successfully. It is excellently acted throughout. And most importantly, each episode has an outstanding resolution to the puzzling case featured throughout each episode.



    The focus of each episode Jonathan Creek (named after the lead character) is an unusual, dark tale - perhaps a murder, kidnapping or robbery - with one problem: it appears to be a situation impossible to have occured. Maddy Magellan (writer) and Jonathan Creek (magician's right-hand man; mastermind) are always on hand to help figure out what exactly happened. I can;t say too much more without revealing too much, but suffice to say each episode has a very unique conclusion to an otherwise incomprehensible tale.



    The secondary stories often feature magician Adam Klaus, to which Creek is a trick/set designer, getting into some kind of funny mishap. These stories are not usually the focus of the screen for most of the running time.



    The writing is consistently outstanding, each episode has a decent conclusion, and there's plenty of dramatic tension and humour mixed in.



    Crime/drama/thriller fans, this is highly recommended.moreless

    3 0