From Hero to Zero: The Sudden Decline of Parenthood's Joel Graham

By Nick Campbell

Feb 28, 2014

I've often been accused of being too hard on Julia Braverman-Graham (Erika Christensen). For years, I thought of her as a harpy with a heart of gold, someone who wasn't necessarily one-dimensional or incorrigible, but definitely unaffectedly selfish and quick to minimize the feelings of anyone who wasn't her. I want to believe that it's because she's a Braverman, because she's part of the Bay Area clan whose members are no strangers to jackassery, and not because she's some kind of conditioned misanthrope with hackles raised, a byproduct of being a career-minded, type-A woman in an occupation dominated by boys.

But the more I've thought about it, the more I've come to realize that my opinion of Julia probably wasn't so much a result of my crippling male gaze as it was her husband, the superhuman Joel Graham (Sam Jaeger). Standing next to him must be like understanding what martyrdom is about. Though everyone who's married into the Bravermans can be described as long-suffering—you know, since they don't have the blood of Zeek running through their veins and can't understand the innate self-importance that comes with living for years on the family's Berkley compound—Joel managed to rise above the rest of the rabble. He was a realized domestic demigod, someone who listened, who was compassionate, who ran a home with such alacrity, competence, and sensitivity that it was hard not to love everything he did and marvel at the unending patience he had for a wife who tended to make appearances rather than participate and a daughter whose goal was to be every kid you ever hated in elementary school. Why don't you tattle some more, Syd? Let's really make some friends.

For so long, Joel was a rock in constantly troubled waters, staunch in principle and consistent in action. Even when a statuesque and crunchy mommy from down the street desperately tried to ensnare him for a roll in the granola, he didn't budge. After all, Racquel's advances were simply a moth attracted to the glowing and invulnerable loyalty Joel possessed; sure, Julia had stabby eyes for her at every turn, but I never felt that Yoga Juice Bar Mom really had any sort of power over Joel. To sleep with the neighborhood bendy straw would be unconscionable, and Joel is nothing if not devoted and consummate.

So why is he being such a dick all of a sudden?

Parenthood's fifth has embarked on the long, difficult journey toward an arc that hasn't yet been attempted on the show: honest-to-goodness, therapy-worthy problems that lead to an actual trial separation. It's been a mountain to climb: Julia leaving her job, Victor struggling so much in school that he's being held back, the stress of Joel's business. The Grahams have experienced their fair share of troubling circumstances that culminated when Julia, amidst an emotional (not physical) affair that was relatively amok, got kissed by Roy from The Office.

Julia didn't invite the advances of David Denman's Ed Brooks (though the case could be made that she led him on), didn't show up at his house wearing a Catholic schoolgirl outfit, didn't even offer any signs that she wanted any piece of that. A miscommunication, that's all. It ate her up inside, and—eventually—she confessed to Joel what had transpired. Ed kissed her. It happened. 

Everything we've ever known about Joel led me to believe that the Joel thing to do was chuckle, poke a little fun, and then move on. Unconditional forgiveness seems to be one of those lofty traits only superhumans like him could possess. But it wasn't like that. Joel. Flipped. The eff. Out.

What's more, he basically blew up everything around him. The lingering kiss led to an unrecognizable coldness in Joel, to a pettiness that was unbecoming. And while we might be able to understand his feelings of jealousy and anger, the extent to which he acted on them—by moving out of the house—seemed desperately disproportionate to the supposed catalyst. Even though we saw the man deteriorating over the course of multiple episodes, when he came to that decision, I said myself, "Wow. That escalated quickly." And why is that?

Joel amassed an amazing amount of capital over the years as the touchstone to reality the Bravermans could certainly use more of. There are few characters on television today who have the Superman problem, where they're so invulnerable to the whims of humanity, so steadfast in principle, that they come off as bland and boring. Joel is trustworthy and confident in who he is, so what more development could there be? What flaws exist within him that we can see in ourselves? He's basically been dehumanized, like a figure in a myth.

I can't really argue that he's turned heel, because he's not so much a villain as he is a completely different person. Over the years there have been slights to his manhood, like Zeek trying to teach Joel—a construction supervisor—how to tile a roof. It was funny, but also very telling of Joel's position in the family as a house husband. He played second fiddle to Julia's alpha-dogging for so long, mostly without complaint. So it's not like he doesn't have a reason to be mad about his station. But does this have to be why?

Maybe my concern stems from seeing this sort of thing play out on other shows, but with a different result. Staying in the Katims-verse, Friday Night Lights' Tami Taylor accidentally strung along that poor science teacher for basically forever, and he did just about everything for her. Then he planted one on her outside of teacher's karaoke. Did Coach Taylor threaten to blow up the marriage? Did he move out of the house to a sad bachelor pad? No. He laughed it off. Of course, it wasn't without a stern warning to the man who would try to seduce Tami, but it was no big whoop. And Eric Taylor is a far more violent and prideful man than Joel Graham and his bruised ego.

I suppose that's the most disappointing aspect of Joel's decline: how petty and sad he's become in the wake of a great big nothing. The result is a dramatic disconnect between the man we've understood to always put family first, and this passive-aggressive douche who sits in therapy with his wife who wants to reconcile and says "I don't know" about whether he can possibly get over this indignity. If to be a cuckold is to grow horns, Joel would barely have a headache. And yet, he's continuing this weird charade of a man who's had to make some tough decisions after a betrayal. It's like watching a rock wither.

This is frittered capital; Joel's significance is being sacrificed for the sake of a quasi-divorce story. It's rare to see Parenthood execute a storyline without properly setting the table, but maybe the reason this escalation seems so sudden and foolish is that Joel had such a long way to fall before he could even find himself tangled in the problems of a mortal. People have started looking for other reasons why this could be happening. Did he react so dramatically because he's also involved in an emotional, and possibly physical, affair with his boss (Sonya Walger's Meredith Peet)? Is Joel hiding something dastardly? It's doubtful. But the alternative is that one of the few people associated with the Bravermans who hasn't become a sobbing, beta mess at their feet is suddenly so very whiny and so eye-rollingly committed to a doomed path that it almost seems like he's doing it just so that Julia—who's looked downright charming since Joel has started working petty—will chase him a little. It's pathetic to watch. And it seems like we've lost that hero character for good.

What are your feelings on the current Joel/Julia situation? Did Joel overreact? Has your opinion of Julia changed after seeing her struggle to keep it together in that empty house? 

  • Comments (51)
Add a Comment
In reply to :
  • MonicaMorgan7555 Yesterday

    After being in relationship with him for 3 years, he broke up with me, I did everything possible to bring him back but all was in vain, I wanted him back so much because of the love I have for him, I begged him with everything, I made promises but he refused. I explained my problem to someone online and she suggested that I should rather contact a spell caster that could help me cast a spell to bring him back but I am the type that never believed in spell, I had no choice than to try it, I mailed the spell caster, and he told me there was no problem that everything will be okay before three days, that my ex will return to me before three days, he cast the spell and surprisingly in the second day, it was around 4pm. My ex called me, I was so surprised, I answered the call and all he said was that he was so sorry for everything that happened, that he wanted me to return to him, that he loves me so much. I was so happy and went to him, that was how we started living together happily again. Since then, I have made promise that anybody I know that have a relationship problem, I would be of help to such person by referring him or her to the only real and powerful spell caster who helped me with my own problem and who is different from all the other ones out there. Anybody could need the help of the spell caster, his email is DRABEGDIONSPELLCASTER@GMAIL.COM you can email him if you need his assistance in your relationship or any other problem. you can email him if you need his assistance in your relationship or any other problem.

  • lisa958 Apr 06, 2015

    No one could have ever made me believe that the letter I'm about to write would actually one day be written. I was the world’s biggest sceptic. I never believed in magic spells or anything like that, but I was told by a reliable source (a very close co-worker) that Dr Matamah is a very dedicated, gifted, and talented person, and after much “cajoling,” she (my co-worker) got me to visit this website. It was one of the best things I have ever done. My love life was in shambles; I had been through two divorces and was on the brink of a third. I just couldn't face another divorce, and I wanted to try harder to make our relationship work, but my husband didn't seem to care. So, with nothing but my pride to lose, I checked it out. I was flabbergasted. Dr Matamah is for REAL. He did whatever magic he does, and lo and behold – no more than TWO DAYS later, I had my husband back! It was like a miracle! He suddenly wanted to go to marriage counselling, and we’re doing very, very well, on the road to recovery! Love and Many Blessings Back to You! Contact Dr Matamah through his email on

  • sharronjenna Mar 30, 2015

    Hello Every one out here!!
    I want to share my testimony and my happiness with you all in this site, last year my husband left me for another woman in his working place and he abandon me and my 2kids, everything was so hard for me because i love him so much, so i saw the testimonies of Dr.Camaraho he has been helping ladies in getting there husband back so i contacted him and he help me to cast a return spell for my husband and in 3 days my husband left the other woman and he come back to me with so much love and caring. i will never forget this help that Dr.Camara gave to me and my children.if you are here you need help to get you lover back you can contact him through this email CAMARALOVESPELL@LIVE.COM, i am proud to be on his testimony page.

  • Mariacharos Mar 26, 2015

    Am Mario Charos from Switzerland, i want to share my great testimony about Doctor Ebakor the great spell caster that brought back my Husband within 12 to 16 hours. When i contacted Doctor Ebakor i never taught that this would have been possible but to my greatest surprise after 12 to 16 hours of me contacting Doctor Ebakor my Husband called me and said that he is ready to make up for lost time and he wants me to forgive him and accept him back as my lover, While until this moment my eyes are full of surprise because i never thought that he will come back to me again. At this moment i have nothing to say than to thank Doctor Ebakor for his great powers and for making use of it to help those in need. Contact Doctor Ebakor via email:

  • sarahjanebloggs37 Mar 17, 2015

    My name is Bloggs, I want to use this opportunity to tell everyone about Dr Stanley on how he help me reunited with my husband after 2 months of separation. My husband divorce me because he saw another woman in his office and he said to me that he is no longer in love with me anymore and decide to divorce me.I seek for help from the internet where i found a testimony of someone testifying about the goods works of Dr. Stanley and i contact him and explain my problem to him and he cast a spell for me which i use to get my husband back within 2 days and now my husband is now back with me with so much love and care.If you need his help also you can Email him via or call +2348038139297..

  • JessicaSaltman Mar 16, 2015

    My husband left us a year ago when we had our last kid because he has always been afraid of having kids (so embarrassing). I was in a dark world, things did not go as we have planned when we exchanging our marriage vows, he hates kids and never plays with them even on their birthdays; he always wants to have me alone for reasons best known to him. I tried teaching him ways to love kids but he constantly keeps his distance away from them which made them to think that he is not their father.
    He finally left us to an unknown destination when he couldn’t bear with the pressure around him. I suffered and convinced them that their father will change to a better man and come back. This made me stand by my word because I don’t want to be a lying Mother, so I had to find ways to bring back my Boo as a changed man until I overheard a woman in a mall talking to her friend about a Spell Doctor called Dr.Osaz who help her sister get back her husband; so I quickly asked her if she can help me with the doctor’s contact if he can help me.Thanks to her and Dr. Osaz who changed my husband and brought him back to us as I promised our kids. He now loves them and plays with them. Dr. Osaz him a lovely Father and Husband. I am so happy that I finally fulfilled the promise I made to my kids. Contact Doctor Osaz if you are suffered relationship humiliation via: spirituallove @ hotmail . com

  • sergionavarro5987 Dec 31, 2014

    I just googled "parenthood joel overreacted to julia" to get here, so yeah, I think he overreacted.

  • karenbethcourcy Dec 12, 2014

    as I sit here and re-watch season 5 my blood is boiling over the way Joel has made a complete 180 from the character we have gotten to know over the past 4 years before this.

    I can't believe what a hypocrite he is being.. was it not him that was kissed by that weird freak of a woman who hit on him all the time Raquel? Was it not Joel to told Julia that she hit on him, kissed him and made moves at him all the time and yet you didn't see Julia leave the house and marriage. Joel sits there and gets pissed off that Julia went to Ed brooks house, yet how many times was Raquel at Joel and Julia's house while she stood there giving him a kiss on the cheek calling him JOELSKI's Give me a break! You didn't see Julia taking a hissy fit and leaving the house and marriage over that and yet Joel can't put his big panties on long enough to save the good marriage they have had for their kids?

    The writers got this one SO WRONG! They gave us no warning before turning him into a total PRICK! then they have the audacity to try and change joel back to the GOOD GUY in season 6 by trying to have him BEG for Julia back saying "oh I know I hurt you"... GIVE ME A BREAK! this whole Julia and Joel storyline took a dive into the "this makes no sense! pool!

    Joel was a total dick in season 5 .. Julia is far from perfect, and she has had her moments of being selfish around Joels job, but it was nothing to leave the marriage and the kids for! Julia could have been a lot more supportive of his job, we all agree with that.. but it was not worth leaving the marriage and their kids ..

    in season 6, julia was SO RIGHT to say to him "YOU LEFT US, I asked you to give me and the marriage a chance, you LEFT US" .. I don't think he desrrved a chance back, but that is my opinion! She asked joel time and time again not give up on her .. but he still was a prick and left ..

    the writers really messed season 5 up in a huge way.. totally inconsistent with what they gave us for 4 years before.. this was NOT Joel at all..

  • DJMODOUBT Nov 21, 2014

    I feel the EXACT opposite... Definately led that man on and they kissed each other. she was always demeaning and condescending to Joel and the fact that he is somehow being portrayed as the one who has making up to do is sickening...

  • DNACODEFLESH Nov 13, 2014

    Joel's character is emblematic of most loser man-boys that have raided American society. He is a complete sissy with ZERO accountability and definitely a "victim" type like so many manginas have become.
    The FUNNIEST thing about this??? He has the nerve to overreact to an act while completely forgetting the completely disdainful and disrespectful way he spoke to his WIFE when she showed up at his work.
    "WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?!?!?" and the condescending tone he used in front of a female supervisor no less?
    Who the f&&& talks like that to someone you allegedly love so much that weeks later you show the epic martyr-hurt for?!?! Wow, you love her so much to leave for wounded pride, but boy you gave two craps about her and shamed her in PUBLIC (a point I was shocked you failed to mention).
    Men like Joel in real life (definitely one of the worst characters in TV history) should either kill themselves or get run over by a bus.
    The show as a whole really has only 1-2 likeable characters to boot. Notice how none of them seem to have NO friends? Their elitist behavior and attitudes are just....too funny.
    FYI the Matriarch? WOW she's a piece too...
    Nuff said.
    Now who wants to drive the bus that turns man-boy Joel into Jelly?

  • karenbethcourcy Dec 12, 2014

    I Totally agree with you! and also was it NOT joel who was kissed by that nature freak Raquel years before... was it not Joel was admitted to julia that Raquel hit on him.. did you see julia leaving the marriage and kids over that? NO in fact Julia was mature about it and even let Raquel's daughter still remain friends with Sidney. How many times did Julia come home to Raquel being at the house with her daughter and giving Joel a kiss on the cheek in front of Julia calling him JOELSKI? did Julia once give up on the marriage or him because of that? HELLO!!! talk about being a total hypocrite!

    Joel was a total prick in season 5.. and then begs for his wife back in season 6? give me a break!

    I agree with your response....

  • karenbethcourcy Dec 12, 2014

    This comment has been removed.

  • See More Comments (30)