Episode Reviews (6)
- SORT BY:
One of the best "Prime Directive" shows on TNG and a very clever story.
This wasn't the first episode in TNG to center around the routinely-defied Prime Directive, but it was definitely the first one to actually be enjoyable. It was also arguably the best episode from the beginning of season 3 (though you could make a case for "The Survivors").
It's a testament to the improvement of the show that two ideas that had repeatedly tripped up the writers in earlier seasons - the moral dilemmas generated by the Prime Directive and the supposed moral superiority of 24th century humans - actually turn out to be strengths here.
While the anti-religious theme of this episode is somewhat strident, it actually makes the episode a lot more interesting because of the role into which Picard is thrust. The interactions between him and Nuria - particularly the scene in the observation lounge - is probably the highlight of the episode.
And it's nice to see how the Enterprise, confronted with a violation of the Directive, is forced to come up with ever more elaborate plans to correct that mistake - each of which fails and compounds the problem. Life doesn't always work out too neatly.
Two other observations - while Dr. Crusher's role in the episode is quite small, the tension between her Hippocratic Oath and Picard's obsession with playing the book sets up the rest of the episode nicely. And the actors who played the Mintakans - particularly Nuria - did a good job, certainly much better than the flunkies who appeared in "The Ensigns of Command".moreless
All worship The Picard!
It's a "Prime Directive" episode, which, of course, consists of (accidently) breaking the Federation's most valued law and putting the pieces back together again. After mixed results with some previous attempts ("Justice", "Pen Pals") the writers discard the heavy-handed preachyness and tell a nice sci fi story with a good mix of comedy and drama – using Troi and Riker particularly well.. The episode even touches on the developments of religion, a theme the Trek tv shows generally avoid. The result is a good episode, although surprisingly Voyager would top it with a similar but more ambitious idea in their sixth season episode "Blink of an Eye".moreless
This story should be shared with the world.
Possiably the best line of any Episode comes from Jean Luc Picard: Horrifying. (pause) Dr. Barron, your report describes how rational these people are. Millennia ago, they abandoned their belief in the supernatural. Now you are asking me to sabotage that achievement, to send them back into the Dark Ages of superstition and ignorance and fear. No! We will find some way to undo the damage we've caused. I like how he compares the belief in false gods and the supernatural as being in the "Dark Ages" If only we as a society today had someone to pull us from our "Dark Ages" and throw us into the reality that you don't need to believe in an all powerful supernatural entity to strive and succeed as a society.moreless
Awesome episode showing the difficulty of maintain the prime directive
*** Spoilers ahead ***
One of my alltime favourite episodes. Well with Sam Wise in it, could it have been anything else?
The basic premise of the plot centers around the Prime Directive and the harm interference can cause if it is not adhered to accidently or otherwise. It also draws upon a first contact situation between two races with vastly differing techological advances. This leads to a a clash of cultures between one that has recently rejected the notion of dieties and one that is advanced enough to view religion with skeptism.
A scientific expedition, is observing a pre-warp civilisation from a clandestine base. From the off, we are drawn into the story as an explosion causes the camouflaging shield of the outpost to fail. Inevitably this draws a number of the natives towards the outpost to investigate the gleaming reflection the base causes against the bright sun.
Then a sequence of predictable events where the natives witness the power of the Enterprise crew and their "magic" leads to a scene where Ray Wise's character is beamed onto the Enterprise to save his life, but sees the "all powerful" being The Picard before having his memory wiped.
His daughter having seen the effects of 24th century technology returns to warn her village. Her father then returns and communicates his vision that he was saved by a God-like entity, thus generating the sort of hysteria one could expect from such a first contact.
More potentially-catastrophic events occur throughout the episode which increase the stakes by leaps and bounds as one of the scientists is found by the natives and held to appease The Picard. Troi and Riker descend incognito to attempt a rescue and assess the damage that has been caused by the revelation of the scientific outpout.
Once the situation is serious enough when Troi gets accosed and a proposal to sacrifice her is made, the village elder is brought onboard to attempt to show her that they are not gods. Picard predictably fails until one of the research party dies.
This leads to a life threatening situation for Picard as he fails to convince even the most vehrmently fanatical of followers (Wise) that he is not one of their spirit gods.
An execellent well paced episode, that provides an excellent distraction from the usual conflict/ resolution/ mystery solving episodes that make up the bulk of ST plot devices. Wise is great, but in truth all the supporting actors make this a very special episode. In my eyes a classic story.moreless
Picard mistaken as a god.
- Fascinating story about a civilization's progression out of blind faith/theism and into an age of reason.
- Surprisingly strong anti-religious perspective for such a mainstream show. Picard REALLY objected to the idea of playing a god.
- Terrific story full of ideas, discussion starters. This is a great example of what science fiction is all about. Very meaty material!
Kid's view: - When the Mintakans continued to make the incorrect deductions and kept on inventing more reasons for why Picard WAS a god . . . this was funny and drew me more into the story.
- we got to see troi & riker as vulcans and in funny old-fashioned clothes.
- i never pictured picard with a "the" before his name. it was funny. :)
- i thought picard should have worn a greek god costume down to the planet (complete with robe and those leafy things on his head)moreless
A team of Federation anthropologists are studying the Mintakans on Mintaka III. To avoid violating the prime directive a technology known as a hologram generator is being used to conceal a federation outpost. A explosion in the outpost causes a power fail
A team of Federation anthropologists are studying the Mintakans on Mintaka III. To avoid violating the prime directive a technology known as a hologram generator is being used to conceal a federation outpost. A explosion in the outpost causes a power failure thus exposing the outpost to the two Mintakans Liko and Oji. Liko touches the outpost and is electrocuted. Dr Crusher has Liko and beamed to sick bay. While in sickbay Dr Crusher cures Liko and tries to wipe his memory of everything he has seen of the "Federation". I rate this one a 7.8 for vulcan-like originality.moreless