America's Got Cable: BBC America vs. truTV


Welcome to another head-thumping week of America's Got Cable: The Search for the Nation's Finest Basic Cable Channel!


OLD BUSINESS: Attractive teens and the Lord go together like peanut butter and chocolate! Congratulations goes to...


*************************************ABC FAMILY*************************************


Good call, you guys. Also, thanks for keeping in mind that two channels don't have to be super similar in order to vote on which one is more entertaining. That is the ONLY criteria that matters, right? I loved these comments:

Amaya-Fire: "I had enough teenage drama in high school. GSN gets my vote."

CrimeDramaBee: "Hearing crazy people yelling all the time just gets to me, I guess. ABC Family because I actually enjoy watching some of their shows."

LPHeadstrong: "This was the first AGC article I read! Until now I thought this was a reality show that got a lot of attention on TV.com! Huh. The more you know. Also, ABC Family!" [Ed. note: Haha, welcome?]


NEW BUSINESS: This next matchup will be covered to death by the world's trashiest tabloids!


BBC America

Background: Americans may not know this, but anyone who watches TV in the UK is forced to pay a mandatory "television license" fee, which basically pays for the BBC. Can you imagine if WE had to directly pay for Bachelor Pad or Marriage Ref? There'd be rioting in the streets! Good thing we pay for things the old-fashioned way, staring blankly at advertisements and then feeling mysteriously compelled to buy these products later. Anyway! BBC America launched in 1998 as a member of the Discovery Channel family and because UK citizens shouldn't have to pay for EVERYTHING, it runs advertising. Since its inception, BBC America has been mostly a repository for the BBC's formidable array of original series, but lately has begun to rerun American shows as well as produce original content.

Original Programming: Define "original." A majority of BBC America's programming is original TO US, but let's be real, it's mostly reruns or simulcasts of the mothership's programming. In addition to its daytime BBC news coverage, some of the more well-known shows include Doctor Who, Law & Order: UK, various Gordon Ramsay shows (the ones with British contestants), Top Gear, Being Human, Peep Show, Primeval, the James May specials, and upcoming BBC America co-production The Fades.

Reruns: Lately BBC America's been airing more American reruns for some reason, including Battlestar Galactica, The X-Files, Star Trek: The Next Generation, and The Tudors.

Why It's The Best: Not to be a nerd about it, but IT'S THE BBC. Look at the stats: At least 85 percent of the BBC's programming is awesome. It's a scientific fact.

Why It's The Worst: Many BBC series were not intended to include commercial breaks, so it can be awkward when an episode suddenly cuts to a tampon commercial midway through a scene.


truTV

Background: Way back in 1991, America demanded a courtroom-themed cable channel—and thus Court TV was born. Jointly owned by Time Warner, NBC, and Liberty Media, the network burst onto the scene with wall-to-wall live coverage of the Menendez trial, and most importantly, the O.J. Simpson murder trial. Like many other single-concept cable channels, the network soon began to incorporate fictional programming, reality shows, and reruns into its schedule. Then a 2006 buyout by Turner Broadcasting led to a name change: truTV.

Original Programming: During the daytime, truTV continues its bread-and-butter coverage of tabloid-friendly trials, with commentary by various on-air personalities which have included Nancy Grace, Ashleigh Banfield, Dan Abrams, and Star Jones. But its primetime schedule is largely stocked with inexpensive reality shows, including Bait Car, Hardcore Pawn, Big Brian The Fortune Seller, Forensic Files, Las Vegas Jailhouse, Operation Repo, Lizard Lick Towing, Most Shocking and World's Dumbest.

Reruns: As its original programming slate has increased, truTV has been mostly able to get by rerunning its own content. But it IS worth noting that the network used to air Homicide: Life on the Street (a.k.a. the best show ever). Credit where credit's due.

Why It's The Best: If you like true crime, truTV gives you a pretty great look into the minutiae of the criminal justice system as cases unfold.

Why It's The Worst: This channel gave birth to Nancy Grace, and while I can appreciate her various talents, which include night vision and super-sonic screams, she's not really something I want in my house. You know?


Official TV.com Verdict:

I generally like it when cable channels aren't painful to the senses. BBC America!

But now it's your turn! COMMENT BELOW and tell us your vote: BBC America or truTV? And make your case! What do you love or hate about each channel?


Want to catch up on past battles? Head over to the America's Got Cable archives.


Follow TV.com writer Price Peterson on Twitter: @pricepeterson

Comments (18)
Submit
Sort: Latest | Popular
What happen to the cool voting buttons?
Reply
Flag
BBCA, because Graham Norton knows how to host a Talk show. I feel bad for all the people who say they don't get the BBC. I'm in Northern SD and I get the BBC.
Reply
Flag
BBC America for sure! I'll take actual international news coverage over marathons of "48 hours" any time, any place! Though, I do love "Homicide Life on the Street" and think it is one of the best shows ever created in its genre. That show gave rise to a detective character who has appeared on 3 separate TV shows as the same character :-)
Reply
Flag
BBCA - i wish i had the network. instead i end up renting the shows, and buying Doctor Who & Torchwood.
Reply
Flag
I like to pretend that i am a fancy brit when i watch TV so defenitely BBC AMERICA. btw, its good.
Reply
Flag
BBC America. I don't even get the channel and I know it's better. I wish I got the channel.
Reply
Flag
BBC America theres no contest.
Reply
Flag
Blah. Neither. I miss CourtTV.
Reply
Flag
BBC America
Reply
Flag
BBC America, cant wait for Nerdist to air
Reply
Flag
I didn't see past BBC.
Reply
Flag
BBC America because it has pretty good reruns- I mean original programming for us Americans.
Reply
Flag
I choose BBC America because TruTV doesn't sound like it has a wide variety of shows to draw in a "Tru" crowd.
Reply
Flag
truTV has nothing for me to watch, so it's America BBC for me. Being Human, Primeval, and The Inbetweeners are among the good shows they have. I could also include the great Robin Hood series that ended a couple of years ago. I even catch their weekend talk show Graham Norton once in a while. With these, BBCA is far more entertaining than truTV.
Reply
Flag
BBC America, if nothing else then just for Doctor Who. truTV is a horrible horrible waste of resources, as are most news channels
Reply
Flag
Tru TV. I would rather watch Worlds wildest police vdeos than a drama.
Reply
Flag
I like both channels, so this is a hard one. Thanks TV.com for this hard choice. I think I will vote for BBC America.
Reply
Flag
Definitely BBC America. Most especially for Dr. Who, but also for the hysterical Law and Order: UK ads that show clips of the main characters using British slang with subtitles. Plus, with them showing both Law and Order: UK and Battlestar Galactica reruns, it is working hard to become the Jamie Bamber channel. All they have to do is add a few Horatio Hornblower marathons and they'll be all set.
Reply
Flag

Like TV.com on Facebook