Doctor Who Is Lighter and Brighter in Peter Capaldi's Final Season

When every other beloved series is being rebooted, revived or remade, when every mediocre movie spawns a sequel or -- heaven forbid -- a poorly-made franchise, very little of pop culture feels particularly novel or exciting at the moment. With more than 50 years under its belt, Doctor Who should probably be running on fumes, and we should be delirious from breathing them in over the years.

And yet the iconic British sci-fi series somehow manages to make its repetitive nature feel as exciting now as it did during our own first adventure in the TARDIS, whether that was during the show's original run or after Russell T. Davies revived it in its current state in 2005.

The long-running show's greatest and most imaginative asset has always been its ability to reinvent itself by inserting new actors into the roles of Doctor and companion when someone decides to depart the role. And while we should probably be bored or unmoved by watching the same illusion play out again and again after all this time, we're not. There's something beautiful and sweet about watching the Doctor's face light up at the prospect of sharing all of time and space with someone new. There's something oddly comforting about new companions making the same "it's bigger on the inside" comment the first time they step inside the TARDIS' blue doors.

Doctor Who: Everything you need to know about Season 10

Each time Doctor Who reinvents itself -- which seems to be approximately every three seasons of late -- it's a bit like coming home to a house where everything is the same but the furniture's been rearranged. You're definitely going to trip over the couch in the middle of the night when you get up for a glass of water, but it's still the same inviting couch you curl up on every Saturday. It only takes a little while to adjust to this new reality, but eventually you do... until you you get a bit bored and move the couch against the other wall and start the entire process over.

Doctor Who's Season 10 premiere, titled "The Pilot," is the beginning of this process, and altogether it is a successful reintroduction back into the world of Doctor Who, which has been off the air since December 2015 save for a pair of Christmas specials. But it's also a successful introduction for the Doctor's new companion Bill (Pearl Mackie), an energetic young woman who works at the university where the Doctor (Peter Capaldi) is currently in disguise as a lecturer, though he's really guarding a mysterious vault for reasons we're not meant to know at the moment.


If we don't include the aforementioned specials, we haven't seen the Doctor since Clara (Jenna Coleman) erased herself from the Doctor's memories and took "the long way 'round" back to Gallifrey in her own TARDIS with Ashildr (Maisie Williams) as her companion. It's unclear how much time has passed since then, but it's probably safe to say it's been a little while given the "Out of Order" sign hung on the TARDIS.

Doctor Who: 9 people we'd like to see as the next Doctor

Clara certainly had her detractors, especially near the end of her run, but Bill is immensely likable from the moment Nardole (Matt Lucas) brings her into the Doctor's office for him to inquire why she attends his lectures when she's not actually a student at the university. She's inquisitive by nature, which is an important trait for any companion, but while Clara was intrinsically linked to the Doctor, Bill is like most of the show's other companions: she's just a girl thirsting for a bit of adventure in a life where there's been none. She's Rose when she worked in a shop, she's Donna as a temp, she's Amy working as a kissogram.

But Bill also stands out from the others who've come before. Her reactions to the Doctor and to the TARDIS are unique and a little baffling at first -- she compares the inside of the TARDIS to a kitchen; it takes her longer than most to grasp that the TARDIS can travel through space and time -- and the show knows how to play all of it for laughs, which is a nice change of pace after the dark, sometimes overwrought, dramatics of the last couple seasons. Bill also asks questions that no one has asked before, like "Doctor What?" instead of the typical "Doctor Who?" and why the TARDIS is called the TARDIS when the Doctor's native tongue isn't English and the acronym from "Time and Relative Dimension in Space" relies on the words being in English. "People don't generally bring that up," says the Doctor.

Despite the escape from reality Doctor Who regularly provides via trips to far off planets in galaxies on the other side of the universe, the driving force of the series isn't this sense of adventure, it's the relationship between the Doctor and his companion. It's why Matt Smith's Eleven never quite fit with Coleman's Clara; he was bonded to Karen Gillan's Amy in such a deep way that the producers brought her back for his emotional swan song. It's why Freema Agyeman's perfectly brilliant Martha was regularly pushed aside for Billie Piper's Rose during David Tennant's run. Certain Doctors are simply bonded to certain companions in more meaningful ways, and despite the Doctor's emotional tether to Clara -- which we were told existed but some may say never quite felt genuine -- it also feels a bit like we're still waiting for Capaldi's Doctor to share that bond with someone. Might Bill be that person?

Class: Is the Doctor Who spin-off worth your time?

Though we've only seen one episode so far, their teacher-student dynamic is sustained in comedy and also feels reminiscent of the relationship that existed between Donna (Catherine Tate) and Ten in that both women are vocal about their feelings but neither has any romantic interest in the Doctor. In fact, Bill is the show's first openly gay companion -- John Barrowman's Captain Jack Harkness was bisexual and never a full-time companion -- which is refreshing but also a relatively easy way to eliminate a nagging piece of the show's history since the Doctor became a romantic lead during Tennant's run. There exists a possibility for Twelve and Bill to become bantering best friends in much the same way Donna and Ten were, and that's exciting after spending years immersed in a convoluted plot with a Doctor-like companion who held the Doctor's life in her hands.

With Mackie's Bill and Lucas' lovable cyborg Nardole on board, Capaldi's final season in the TARDIS has the chance to start fresh, and after more than half a century spent running from aliens or monsters or weird water-like substances that mimic what it sees (honestly, it's hardly worth explaining at this point), that's the true beauty of Doctor Who. And we can't wait to see where the show takes us next.

Doctor Who airs Saturdays at 9/8c on BBC America.

This article originally appears on TV Guide.com.

Comments (16)
Submit
Sort: Latest | Popular
Apr 17, 2017
I really enjoyed the first episode. Billy seems to act more like what a normal person would react when seeing all this for the first time. I also liked that he had the pictures of his granddaughter and river on his desk, but loved the coffee cup with the old sonic screwdrivers. I hope they keep both companions for the whole season. He looks more relaxed playing the doctor
1
Reply
Flag
Apr 17, 2017
It was a nice fake out with the promos of the girl saying "Exterminate". Making us think the Daleks were upgrading.
Reply
Flag
Apr 17, 2017
Is Bill the Doctor's daughter? Why is the Doctor photographed taking a picture of Bill's mother? There's a missing space between River (wife) and Susan (granddaughter), is this a hint that what's missing is the picture of a daughter? Is the "promise" the Doctor made not to have another human companion to travel with him to Bill's mother?
Reply
Flag
Apr 17, 2017
I just assumed that once Bill said she had very few pictures of her mom that he went back in time and took pictures of her as a gift.
2
Reply
Flag
Apr 17, 2017
Good catch! Forgot about that.
Reply
Flag
Apr 17, 2017
A very nice start for the Doc's final season til the next regeneration. I love that they are touching base with the deep past of Dr. Who with that pic of Susan. I do hope they bring her back in some kind of form. Wouldn't it be crazy if it turned our that "Missy" is actually a warped and confused Susan? I doubt it of course unless they want to ignore a few seasons of history..not that Dr. Who ever does that.
And for the life of me, I liked Clara. I agree that the writing of her character seemed a bit off in the final season. It's like they just didn't know what to do with her but loved Jenna too much to let her go.
Looking forward, I am hoping that the next regeneration means something other than just bringing in a new Doc. Make the Doctor a lady or black....let him come back as the Valyard. Even if it's only for a short time.
Anywho..here is to Peter Capaldi and his final season.
Reply
Flag
Apr 17, 2017
I am hoping that when the original actor who plays the Master returns that we find out Missy has been lying and she is the Rani. Also watching this episode I kept asking myself if this is the same monster from Water on Mars special.
Reply
Flag
Apr 17, 2017
I enjoyed the season opener! Looking forward to the new season. "Doctor What?" awesome!
Reply
Flag
Apr 16, 2017
The text recap is up at tv.com, as soon as it clears the cache.
Reply
Flag
Apr 16, 2017
The Doctor looked twice at the picture of his granddaughter. Wonder if that is a hint that she shows up for an episode this season.
Reply
Flag
Apr 16, 2017
I was thinking that too. The second time especially it seemed to linger on the picture.
1
Reply
Flag
Apr 16, 2017
Adding to this thought I am beginning to wonder if the title of this episode was meant as a double entendre with the second meaning being a reference to "An Unearthly Child" wherein Susan says what TARDIS means.
Reply
Flag
Apr 16, 2017
I am extremely pleased with Bill so far:-)
Reply
Flag

Like TV.com on Facebook