Emmy picks: Supporting Actress, comedy

clockwise (from top left): Krakowski,
Taylor, Sykes, Schall.

The Emmys won't announce its nominations until July 16, but with the 2008-2009 season closed, we've already made our picks. We'll unveil them one day at a time over the course of the next two working weeks (Monday-Friday), with each day presenting a new category.

Today we'll look at the supporting actresses of comedy. What makes a good supporting actress in a comedy? We'll aside from the fact that they aren't the star of the show and do meet the anatomical requirements, a good supporting actress is like icing on the cake--they can often be the best part.

Jane Krakowski, 30 Rock

Role: Jenna Maroney
In a cast full of neurotics, Jenna makes the others look relatively sane--well maybe not Tracy. Doing classic "dumb blonde" is easy--doing it like Jane isn't.

Holland Taylor, Two and a Half Men

Role: Evelyn Harper
The foil to Charlie on America's most-watched comedy, Evelyn is in the Lucille Bluth (Arrested Development) family of TV mothers--self-absorbed, insufferable, and darned funny.

Kristen Schaal, Flight of the Conchords

Role: Mel
As the Conchords' obsessed fan, Mel doesn't rely on subtlety to get her feelings across. Schaal, on the other hand, performs so many blink-and-you'll-miss-them gestures that make Mel the delightful stalker she is, she can't be overlooked.

Chenoweth, second to nun.

Kristin Chenoweth, Pushing Daisies

Role: Olive Snook
The multi-talented Chenoweth wins us over with her spunky attitude and perfect delivery of the writers' poetic dialogue. And let's face it, she's just plain adorable.

Wanda Sykes, The New Adventures of Old Christine

Role: Barb
As the sidekick to Christine, Barb don't take no shorts. This character was seemingly written specifically for Wanda, and she nails it.

And our winner is: Jane Krakowski. Why does 30 Rock win the Emmy for best comedy every year? Mostly because of its stellar cast, and we can't imagine 30 Rock without Jane.

  • moonlightenvy

    Jane Krakowski is so underrated! She's hilarious!

    Jul 27, 2009
  • JackCHot4Krstn

    It would be a crime to nominate Kristi,for Best supporting actress in a comedy,"Pushing Daisies", and Kristin don't win!!!,nobody remembers the losers!!, Kristin seemed natural as the lovesick Olive,and Kristin's costumes and hairstyles,added more to Olive's personality!!!
    Kristi's 4ft.-11,and a hot piece from Heaven,and she's got a huge exuberance and a high energetic force to come from a tiny sexy "bod"!!

    Jul 23, 2009
  • JackCHot4Krstn

    Kristin WILL win the Emmy for Best supporting actress in a comedy,for Pushing Daisies!!!,usually an award show will honor a very good and Popular(no pun intended LOL),TV show, by giving this show an award at least,since being cancelled before it's time!!! Also Kristi is the only actor nominated,and I would luv for Kristin to win the Grand Slam for great performers,the Tony,an Emmy,a Grammy and an Oscar!! Good Luck and God Bless Kristin !!!!

    Jul 22, 2009
  • drwoowoocl

    Do recurring characters qualify for this category? Sara Gilbert is always a treat whenever she appears on the Big Bang Theory. Her battle of wits with Jim Parsons are one of the best things about that series and she would deserve some Emmy consideration.

    Jul 15, 2009
  • Nipona

    None of them.

    Jun 20, 2009
  • xphilenz

    Portia de Rossi - Better Off Ted. Hands down the totally f@#$ing consistently funniest performance all damn year.

    Jun 12, 2009
  • cavorka777

    no contest holland taylor.

    Jun 11, 2009
  • tvownsLEXIE

    Oh man, I hope this is what the real list looks like, I would be satisfied with any of them!

    Jun 09, 2009
  • remycathy

    Kristin Chenoweth, Pushing Daisies definately

    Jun 08, 2009
  • angeland8

    Holland Taylor

    Jun 08, 2009
  • JavaJunkie4Life

    I adore Jane, but if Kristin Chenoweth doesn't win for PD, I'll be outraged. She was PERFECT as Olive.

    Jun 08, 2009
  • mcwilly104

    Kristin Chenoweth is amazing and Olive was the best character on Daisies next to Emerson. If only she and Jane could tie, that would be perfect.

    Jun 08, 2009
  • joenamherst

    Since most critics (very few viewers)are mesmerized by 30rock, why don't you fill all your nominations for comedy actress and supporting comedy actress with people from 30rock? Comedy Actress and Supporting Comedy Actress:
    Tina Fay
    Jane Kraskowski
    Latrina Bowden
    Tracy Morgan....He is sorta fem.
    Amy Polar......I had to think of another woman since this is a sexist male dominated cast!

    Jun 08, 2009
  • Badfluffy

    I like Krakowski but honestly her part in 30Rock is getting smaller and smaller and I can definitely see the show without her. Chenoweth on the other hand brought a lot to a show that was unfortunately one of the strike's casualty... My vote goes to Chenoweth.

    Jun 08, 2009
  • aldaros23

    out of these, Wanda

    Jun 06, 2009
  • FriendsSvuLost8

    Kristin Chenoweth deserves to win. (She should of won last year)

    Jun 06, 2009
  • acmb

    Kristin Chenoweth for sure deserves to win.

    Jun 06, 2009
  • TvFreak7

    WANDA SYKES. new adventures of old christine needs to be recognized but to lose to a show with tina fey makes u feel better. 30 rock is a good show but i caught on to it so at least it should win if wanda doesnt

    Jun 05, 2009
  • emma5000

    i'm totally rooting for kristin chenoweth! :)

    Jun 04, 2009
  • winterbehaviour

    I don't know how 30 Rock keeps winning that has got to be the most overrated show I have ever seen. Kristin Chenoweth should win this for sure, she missed out last year.

    Jun 04, 2009
  • Water78

    Jane Krakowski all the way

    Jun 03, 2009
  • TV-Tome-Vits

    Why are you talkin'bout Kyra Sedwig?This is for Oustanding SUPPORTING Actress In A COMEDY Series.

    Jun 03, 2009
  • CLGTweety5

    I hope Kyra Sedgwick of The Closer wins! She deserves it!

    Jun 03, 2009
  • rle11wb

    30 rock won an Emmy because of Jane? Your blatant attempts to get people to respond just to create page views is laughable. The show won for best comedy because of: 1) the writing; 2) the ensemble; and 3) the competition (or lack thereof).

    Jun 03, 2009
  • SoN2Alex

    I'm not sure if there's an emmy category for guest roles but Alex O'Loughlin's portrayal of a serial killer on Criminal Minds was definitely emmy worthy!!!

    Jun 03, 2009
  • dflipkyuzosan24

    jane krakowski better be nominated lol, she done a really good job this year especially in the episode "believe in the stars"

    Jun 02, 2009
  • mcwilly104

    I really like Kristen Chenoweth, she is awesome. But I agree Jane is the best. She plays her role so well but doesn't get lost in the stereotype. She brings a unique sense of craziness to Jenna that is completely original. Jane is often overlooked and hopefully she'll at least get nominated, if she doesn't win.

    Jun 02, 2009
  • patty_h

    Holland Taylor is by far the best one on the list

    Jun 02, 2009
  • TimSpot

    ha - i called 30 rock a drama... sheesh get it together tim!

    Jun 02, 2009
  • budde22

    Definitely Ms. Kristin Chenoweth of Pushing Daisies. Her performance was flawless. She better get the Emmy this year.

    Jun 02, 2009
  • sequoa84

    30 rock has had a dull 3rd season..i dont expect it to win any emmy's this time. As for best supporting (comedy) actress, i would go for holland taylor. Her recurring role is just too good..or possibly Felicity Huffman again!!!

    Jun 02, 2009
  • fantasy43

    Kristin Chenoweth!

    Jun 02, 2009
  • happy46

    I hope Holland Taylor wins. She is so funny

    Jun 02, 2009
  • pgsuperfan

    How about Traylor Howard from MONK

    Jun 02, 2009
  • IndianaMom

    Besides calling 30 Rock a drama, I agree with your selections. But I'd choose Holland Taylor or Kristne Chenoweth. Jenna is just annoying.

    Jun 02, 2009
  • pgsuperfan

    I don't watch too many comedies they are all junk but I did watch Pushing Daisies so I will go with Kristen Chenoweth

    Jun 02, 2009
  • naturistmingle

    She is beautiful. Some of my friends told me that her nudist profile with some of her pretty nude photos and videos was found on a nudist dating site called Nudistmate.com . Not sure if this is true. However, I will help you guys check it out

    Jun 02, 2009
  • Swink17

    Jane Lynch, Party Down. :)

    Jun 02, 2009
  • Roneteus

    Holland Taylor has it coming! Best in the bunch.

    Jun 02, 2009
  • michael_LB92

    "Why does 30 Rock win the Emmy for best drama every year?" This may be a stupid question... but is this on purpose?

    Jun 02, 2009
  • peon4570

    30 rock is the only one with a chance on this list.

    Jun 01, 2009
  • oceanic6

    No one from The Office?

    Oh well, I hope Holland gets it but the others are also deserving.

    Jun 01, 2009
  • Maverick405

    I would personally choose Holland Taylor, I don't think that Wanda Sykes has any talent at all or if she has she keeps it well hidden!

    Jun 01, 2009
  • ihearty

    Kristin Chenoweth...she deserves it, she's done a fantastic job in everything that she's done. She can not only act, but can sing and dance too! She's superb!!

    Jun 01, 2009
  • kravitzfan12

    I've agree with this list almost whole-heartedly! I personally prefer Wanda Sykes to the other women in the category, but they are all equally deserving to be nominated. I would be thrilled to see Sykes and Krakowski nominated - that would be fantastic!

    Jun 01, 2009

Follow TV.com

Subscribe to Our Free Newsletter