We're moving Forums to the Community pages. Click here for more information and updates.

Shameless: Are You My Mother?

Shameless S02E09: "Hurricane Monica"

Last week's Shameless saw Lip exit the Gallagher household, and this week's saw Monica Gallagher take his place. We met Monica briefly in Season 1, when she returned in an attempt to steal away baby Liam to start a family with her lesbian lover, "Bob." Now, with that phase of her life apparently over and Frank's emotional state in flux following his mother's passing, he asked his ex-wife to return home.

On the morality scale, Monica falls somewhere just south of Frank. In fact, Frank's usual drinking seems quite tame compared to the trouble he can get into with his ex-wife, often via harder drugs. So the family's reaction to Monica's return was rightfully skeptical. Though not a fit parent by any stretch of the imagination, Frank never completely abandoned his children the way Monica did. Even when sober, Monica has always crumbled under the pressure that Fiona lives with every day.

Chloe Webb's casting always seemed appropriate—Monica Gallagher is only a few degrees and decades removed from the Sid and Nancy character that started her career. But her Season 1 appearance was far too short to have developed any chemistry with the Gallagher clan. This week, however, she was the star—pitching in around the house to help Fiona, taking Ian to a gay bar so they could connect as mother and son, and of course, re-kindling her romance with Frank. The reunited Gallagher couple even provided the sweetest moment of the episode as they danced together at The Alibi while the usual bar patrons looked on almost lovingly, remembering a similar scene from many years and Irish car bombs ago.

Away from the changes at the Gallagher house, Lip's search for a new place to stay took him all over Chicago. After Karen asked him to pay $100 per week in rent, he tried forcing his way onto Kev and Veronica's couch and fought off bums for prime sleeping locations on the 'L' before arriving at the most logical spot—Steve's penthouse apartment. Naturally Steve offered a barter for Lip's hacking abilities, this time into someone's voicemail, leading to an impressively timely "I'll do my best, Mr. Murdoch" response.

Lip rooming with Steve is a brilliant move by Shameless's writers, as it quickly established Lip as a wedge between the season-long Fiona/Steve face-off. But getting back into business with Steve will surely lead to trouble, especially with a Brazilian gangster likely involved in the mystery scheme. In fact, the only truly helpful words Lip heard this week came from his UChicago professor buddy, who told him what we've all been screaming at the TV for the last few weeks: "Go back to school!" Even if he comes to realize he should, we now know that Lip has more problems ahead thanks to the episode's final scene, in which Mandy's father Terry burst into the Gallagher kitchen and beat up Ian for getting Mandy pregnant. Wait... Lip?! Again? This time I think it's fairly certain he's the father.

While Monica and Lip dominated this episode, Fiona's quieter struggle is what really sold it for me. Racked with guilt over the ultimatum that drove Lip from the house, she appeared almost powerless to stop her mother from taking the reigns. Despite her typical, erratic behavior, Monica made just enough of the right promises to convince Fiona she could benefit from having another adult-ish figure to lean on for help.

When Frank and Monica brought the bar back to the Gallagher house on a school night, Frank was even able to guilt Fiona into letting Debbie enjoy some attention from her drunk mother: "Nights like tonight are legend. A memory Debs can carry with her always. Don't screw her out of that. It might be the only one she gets." Emmy Rossum delivered another perfect reaction in a season full of them. However drunk he might have been as he said it, Frank's honesty was refreshing. So Fiona backed away to let her sibling have a glimpse of the nights she's likely to be deprived of later.

The Gallagher Family Crib Sheet:

– Karen is ruthless—she stopped by another man's house to tell him that 1) she's pregnant, 2) the baby is his, and 3) she needs money for an abortion. It's becoming clear that Karen might have no idea who the father is, but she's going to profit from her pregnancy as much as possible. She even spelled it out in black and white for Lip: "If there's no money involved, don't get other people's shit on your shoes."

– Lip found a real-time Portuguese-to-English translation tool online in order to translate Estefania's Brazilian phone-sex session. Technology-wise, it wasn't the most realistic moment Shameless has offered, but it certainly sped up the possible removal of Este as an obstacle to Steve getting back with Fiona.

– Steve made a Friday Nights Lights reference! Awesome. "Now I'm off to lead a pack of tiny testosterone animals to victory. Gonna warm 'em up and give 'em my best Friday Night Lights speech about hearts and eyes and some shit. I don't know."

– Last week I questioned where Jody's character might go next, but he was worth bringing back solely for his "University of River Phoenix" line and his goofy ceremony to remove the evil spirits from Sheila's house. Then the writers found their new storyline by having him sleep with Sheila. The best part? Karen got to hear "Kiss from a Rose" while standing outside her mother's room.

– In addition to Frank and Monica's slow dance, the episode offered a few more touching moments, especially the party in the final scene with a speech from Debbie to honor Grammy.


Place your bets: Will Monica remain in the Gallagher household through the end of the season?

Comments (17)
Submit
Sort: Latest | Popular
I don't think Monica's going to stay. She talked about being off her meds in this ep, and they showed her talking about it again in the previews for next week - I think she goes off the deep end.
Reply
Flag
I meant last season, not last week... :P
Reply
Flag
I thoroughly hated Monica and Chloe Webb's acting in season one. She's growing on me a bit with this episode, though. She's still annoying, but the character seems a bit more interesting since her appearance last week.

I still think she's going to make a quick exit next week after stealing the Crisco jar money. Pretty much all Shameless guest characters leave after a couple episodes anyway.
Reply
Flag
I agree that the casting decision with Monica was spot on. I never know what to believe what it comes to her. I want to think that Monica can step up to the plate and help Fiona out, but after hearing that she hasn't been taking her meds, it looks unlikely that will happen.



Question: Was Monica living on her own when Frank asked her to come home? Or was she still living with Bob? I was a little confused on that point. Good review and looking forward to next weeks!
Reply
Flag
Bob knew that Monica had chosen to return to Frank... so I'm guessing they were still living together!
Reply
Flag
Did you not see the previews for the next 3 episodes? Monica's gonna be a huge shit-disturber from this point on. They showed her finding the summer money and going on a bender with Frank or something, looks to be interesting.



In other news, I started watching this show 2 days ago and I'm already all caught up. This show is excellent and I'm totally in need of more! Anyone know if the british version is any good?
Reply
Flag
I watched 4 or 5 seasons of the british version when I was suffering from Shameless US withdravel sickness :-). As mentioned earlier the first season is nearly identical to the american one but then from season two and forward the american differs from the brittish one both in direction and in quality. The US version has a more realistic tone to it.
Reply
Flag
I only watched the first season of the british one... and up to the last episode its pretty much shot for shot with much worse acting

MY understanding as with most british - american shows the american writers take the second season in its own direction. Havent bothered to start watching the next seasons UK for fear of confusion of stories, but as others have noted i've heard its not that good.
Reply
Flag
I haven't seen the British version yet, so take this for what it's worth, but almost every British person I know says the American version is actually the best. I didn't see that coming.
Reply
Flag
There's definitely no guarantee that she'll make it all the way to the end of the season (another 3 episodes) given her history of sudden disappearances.
Reply
Flag
I hate monica so i hope she's not staying much longer....
Reply
Flag
lol great episode and i agree monica's voice is soooo annoying and seriously jody and sheila oh god my bet is monica wont last but soo long
Reply
Flag
Good god that karen character is such a f#c*kin SKANK, just god awful all around. I cannot stand her!!! I actually want her to DIE.
Reply
Flag
I like karen,, probably one of my favourite characters...

She knows what she wants (money) and what she doesnt (baby)

Cant fault her for that... Also the actress is pretty hot.

My money has her either keeping the baby, or doing a Quinn (glee) thing and trying to get it back a year later.
Reply
Flag
Agree so much. Like Ian said, she's like cancer, just keeps coming back. Uggh, that girl.
Reply
Flag
I sure hope not. I cannot stand the actress playing Monica. Something about the way she speaks drives me up the wall.
Reply
Flag
Like she's still reeling from a bad trip on X. or something. probably something.
Reply
Flag

Like TV.com on Facebook