With all respect to his talent, I think Liam doesn't fit for this role at all. Spartacus is a historical person which should be presented as a strong, masculine, with a face and voice of a warrior and a leader. Andy, rest in peace, was the best performer for this role, but he was an actor, not the Spartacus himself. So putting Liam in this role was a big mistake, because we need Spartacus, not someone who reminds Andy only with his face. When I watch the second season It seems like, the producer tried to find someone who reminds Andy but not the Spartacus. I am very disappointed.