TV.com Throwdown the Results Show: Which Network Has the Best Comedy Block?

After a break during which I held my own Thanksgiving Throwdown (sweet potatoes eked out a narrow win over turkey), we're back! Today we tally the results of the question we asked two weeks ago: Which network has the best comedy block? As expected, it was a two-horse race and a late push by one filly barely nudged it ahead of its worthy competition.

ABC and its two-hour block of The Middle, Suburgatory, Modern Family, and Happy Endings just edged out NBC's team of Community, Parks and Recreation, The Office, and Whitney by a vote of 38 to 35, thanks to three late picks for ABC. But this one was neck-and-neck until the bitter end. CBS came in a distant third place, nabbing 16 votes for its block of How I Met Your Mother, 2 Broke Girls, Two and a Half Men, and Mike & Molly. Fox's Animation Domination is still back at the starting gate, as it earned a grand total of zero votes. D'oh!

And now, on to the Graphical Brizeakdownnnn!



Which network has the best comedy block?
ABC, 38 votes | NBC, 35 votes | CBS, 16 votes | Fox, 0 votes
None, 5 votes | ABC/NBC tie, 3 votes | ABC/CBS tie, 3 votes | FX 2 votes


If you only glance at the pizza slices above, it's difficult to tell that ABC beat NBC. It was that close. I also appreciate the few of you who completely ignored the rules and voted for FX, even though it doesn't have a two-hour comedy block. I guess you did that just to hurt my feelings. Also: No one voted for Supernatural. Come on, guys! But the great discussion that took place proved you're all winners. My favorite talking point? Someone managed to weave Perfect Strangers into the conversation. Here are the highlights:


safibwana showed his/her age and said: "ABC, by virtue of having the only lineup that is watchable from beginning to end, but I maintain that the very idea of the primetime schedule and even the network is obsolete in the age of the DVR. The idea of a block of programming should have gone out with the advent of cable and the remote control. The last time I felt compelled to sit through an entire evening of a network's programming was because I was too lazy to turn the VHF knob with a pair of pliers and adjust the tinfoil on the rabbit ears."


bert_lancaster stopped by earth to make this comment: "Community and Parks and Recreation are the two shining lights of network comedy and in my house are prolonging Mr. TV's stay of execution, when Community gets canceled I think Mr. TV might be getting thrown out the window. Along with Mr. Dishwasher who wont stop leaking! I hate you you stupid machine."


LINKCPR stopped punching puppies and skipped his/her anger-management class to say what many of us are thinking: "NBC is planning on shelving Community and has given Whitney a full-season order and very likely a second season on top of that. Just think about that for a second. I know this contest is about the combined quality of the shows currently on the air, but I hate NBC so much right now I couldn't possibly vote for them. So I vote for ABC, if for nothing more than to spite those MOTHER!@$#!#S"


AdityaKartikaP broke the rules and said: "Why not mix them up to create the ultimate dream lineup: Community, How I Met Your Mother, Modern Family, Happy Endings."


Arch_Angel88, who always has something interesting to say, said: "It pains me to say this due to to my unabashed love of Community, but my vote is for ABC. If you would have posed this question last year, I probably would have said NBC. But the Carell-less Office has taken a significant drop in quality and direction, and Whitney is an injurious blight feasting upon our very souls (it also ruined my death pool). Conversely, ABC has an absolutely hilarious show (Happy Endings), a very funny and critically acclaimed show (Modern Family), and hands down the best new comedy of the season (Suburgatory). The accumulative quality of ABC's lineup is just too much for Community and Parks and Rec to beat alone. Needless to say, CBS and FOX are not even in the discussion."


jekyll challenged the entire internet by saying: "Once the unfunny Community is gone in favor of 30 Rock NBC will easily have the best block."


chas031 wins the Most Unusual Awesome Reference award for this: "Seriously Tim?? The BEST ??? On network??? The answer is D. None of the above. I'd rather sit for two hours on YouTube watching Debbie Boone wannabes be their best versions of "You Light Up My Life." Damn... ears are bleeding again... gotta go!!"


But because I'm a stats geek, my favorite comment came from TrevPlatt, who broke things down thusly: "Once again I'm going with the numbers...
ABC: Suburgatory +6, The Middle +5, Happy Endings +5, Modern Family -1 = +15
FOX: Family Guy +5, American Dad +5, The Simpsons +1, Allen Gregory -5 = +6
CBS: HIMYM +5, 2 Broke Girls +1, Mike & Molly 0, Two and a Half Men -5 = +1
NBC: Community +10, The Office 0, Parks and Rec -1, Whitney -10 = -1 (sorry Community)
ABC wins.


Thank you to everyone who voted! We'll be back shortly with a fresh new Throwdown, so sharpen your claws and get ready for another heated debate!


Follow TV.com writer Tim Surette on Twitter: @TimAtTVDotCom

Comments (18)
Submit
Sort: Latest | Popular
TrevPlatt is terrible at math...
Reply
Flag
Hey! My math is ace! That wasn't all of my comment, I explained my reasoning on my original post, also, ABC won so I was right - hence good math!
Reply
Flag
While I'm not sure that all four shows have aired at the same time of the year... FX does have 2 hours of comedy shows on Thursday. (League, Sunny, Archer, Louie) which is a pretty funny block that is consistent almost year round.
Reply
Flag
"Also: No one voted for Supernatural. "



I was unaware of this poll, but know that's what I would've voted for.
Reply
Flag
I missed the voting but would like to follow TrevPlatt's stat's with my own version::



ABC: Suburgatory +0, The Middle +8, Happy Endings +3, Modern Family+5 = +16

FOX: Family Guy +1, American Dad +2, The Simpsons +5, Allen Gregory -5 = +3

CBS: HIMYM +6, 2 Broke Girls +1, Mike & Molly 0, Two and a Half Men -5 = +2

NBC: Community -0, The Office+0, Parks and Rec+5, Whitney -5 = 0

ABC wins. :)



For the record though, if Supernatural was actually in the running I would have voted for it. :)
Reply
Flag
I also missed the voting, but I've always laughed out loud more with FOX's Animation Domination. I enjoy a few of the other comedies like The Middle, Modern Family, Mike & Molly, etc. but have found them more to be 'cute', I guess. I can see why ABC won, though.
Reply
Flag
I pretty much agree with the tie. I still think that NBC will be much improved when "Whitney" is moved out of the block, "Up All Night" into the block, and "30 Rock" comes back. Though, if I could keep "Community" instead of the Carrell-less "The Office" it would be the best block: "30 Rock", "Parks And Recreation", "Community" and "Up All Night". There's a winner.
Reply
Flag
Why is Parks and Rec a minus one???!!!! I love Community, but this season, Parks and Rec has been way better quality and more consistent. I firmly believe that anyone who likes Community and the original Office (ie seasons 1-3) will like Parks and Rec. If they say they don't, it's most likely because they started watching season 1 and stopped. Season 1 of Parks and Rec is nothing like the later seasons.
Reply
Flag
i've never been a fan of mockumentary's - modern family manage it quite well because it doesn't feel like a mockumentary apart from the bits where they sit on the couch (which doesn't happen too much) oh and of course the ones where abed does it simply because it's abed - tried parks but couldn't get through a whole episode (and yes tried s2)
Reply
Flag
Who voted on this? I think its rigged. ABC has a great 1 hour, but thats it..
Reply
Flag
My buddy jekyll is quite the rebel. I missed the voting entirely. I'd have to go with NBC, since Community and Parks and Rec get extra points in my book.
Reply
Flag
Honestly, the best two hours is ABC, but the best hour is NBC, with FX on (Sunny and the League) as a distant second.
Reply
Flag
Wow, jekyll really put himself in the hotseat with that comment.
Reply
Flag
TACCADO! Your alive! How'd you escape those tech savvy GoT nerds. I would love to hear that harrowing tale.



Anyway, bashing Community is almost as bad as bashing GoT. The wrath of millions of Fanboys/girls is most likely poised to descend upon jekyll.
Reply
Flag
yes this is true but at least it deserves all the praise - there are some topics *umme* *lau which are best avoided at all costs - unless you'd vote 1million% for said person - which as a mathematician i cannot participate in!!
Reply
Flag
WTF who says Community sucks that is honestly the stupidest comment I have ever heard in my life Community is pure genius, yes NBC has god awful Whitney that will apparently never die, and Carell-less Office is less than stellar but Parks is really funny and Community is gold if I could only have one show for the rest of my life there would be no contest Community every time! I totally agree with LINKCPR but I am still holding out hope NBC aren't completely stupid but now I want to go punch a wall for what jekyell said
Reply
Flag
You should probably attend LINKCPR's anger management class. Though, I completely agree with what you said, so maybe I should go as well.
Reply
Flag

Like TV.com on Facebook