A plastic surgery patient is dead and Shawn and Gus suspect a local surgeon who inconveniently—or maybe conveniently—happens to be someone whom Henry used to date.
Sam, Dean and Castiel are reunited and search the files of the Men of the Letters to find a film that could help them figure out the third trial. Meanwhile, Metatron asks for Castiel's advice about the problems in Heaven, and Crowley delves into the brothers' past... and some familiar facesmoreless
Raquel should be thrilled after finally securing financing for her project, but she battles feelings of guilt because of the way she made the deal happen. Connor continues his downward spiral and finds himself at a new low. Tariq brings Abby to the studio to record some music, but Kaldrick worries that Abby knows too much about his relationship with Tariq and threatens her to keep her quiet. Meanwhile, Nick continues to struggle on stage but sees things finally start to turn around in his love life. Finally, after Alicia's sexy acting debut goes better better than expected, she feels a renewed sense of optimism that it may open new doors for her dancing career.moreless
Jake returns to Chance Harbor to warn Cassie that unless they find out how her father was killed in the boat fire sixteen years ago, she will endure the same death. Jake suggests an extremely dangerous plan to discover the truth about that fateful day, but Adam and Diana suspect he has ulterior motives. Trying to outmaneuver one another, both Charles and Dawn work to get Ethan on board as an ally. Faye finds herself trapped in a dangerous situation when one of Lee's friends, Callum, stops by the shop.moreless
Sam and Dean deal with a witch who is using her powers to terrorize a small town. They soon discover that she is taking out her anger with her husband, who she discovered was having an affair.moreless
After Jack's truck breaks down repeatedly, Lisa and his family encourage him to buy a new truck; however, they are met with extreme reluctance as Jack tries to let go of the history that is linked with the truck. Meanwhile, it's Amy's end of school formal and she struggles as Ty's behavior seems to indicate to her that he doesn't want to go to the dance with her.moreless