Ichabod and his prepare must find a way to get past the Horsemen and kill an immortal man. To succeed they must turn to the past... and to Hell itself.
While Diana and Lara try to find a way to save Ichabod's soul, Jenny, Jake, and alex take on the undead Hessians after Jobe resurrects them to power the fourth Totem. Meanwhile, Henry is reborn from Ichabod's memories but Jenny isn't convinced by his offer to help.
morelessA mysterious woman, Lara, breaks into the Vault and steals a book, and then uses a time crystal against Jobe. When Diana and Ichabod capture her, she warns that if they don't destroy the Totem of War, Malcolm will destroy their world. Meanwhile, Malcolm captures Jake and Alex.
morelessJobe unleashes a hunger demon as part of Malcolm's master plan, and the team determine to go after it... except for Diana, who would rather find Malcolm and deal with him directly.
Diane takes Molly to the Vault for the girl's first visit. Meanwhile, Molly's imaginary friend stalks the people that she's mad at, and Jake and Alex track down the Vault's previous agent.
Malcolm and Molly share a vision of a future where Malcolm rules the U.S., and Ichabod is an elderly prisoner. Meanwhile, Ichabod and his team try to stop an incendiary outbreak caused by a malevolent djinn.
morelessMolly's father Mitch returns to the States and Diana questions whether she should renew her relationship with her. Meanwhile, Jenny confines Jobe within a warded circle and questions him for information.
Ichabod and Jenny take the others to Sleepy Hollow to recover the fourth piece of the Stone, only to discover Malcolm and Jobe waiting for them.
Malcolm's old partner pays him a visit, just as Ichabod and Diana confront Malcolm with what they've learned. Meanwhile, Diana worries about whether she's a good mother as she considers how tell Molly that the girl is a Witness.
morelessThe Horseman returns... and travels to DC to take a new head: the President. Ichabod and Diana go to Malcolm for help, unaware of his true intentions. Meanwhile, Jake and Alex find evidence confirming Ichabod's original age and confront him with the truth.
morelessA murder is the result of witchcraft, and Diana calls Ichabod in to help the investigation. Meanwhile, Ichabod and Jenny uncover the identity of the new Witness.
Ichabod ends up in DC trying to find the next Witness. Meanwhile, a demon possessing the body of John Wilkes Booth is freed, and the vengeful partner of its first victim is on its trail.
morelessIn the second-season finale, a drug kingpin is taken down, but at a high cost for the folks at the precinct. Meanwhile, Jake makes a huge decision about his future with Laura.
Laura's sister becomes a suspect in a murder investigation in Brooklyn, so Laura tries to stay one step ahead of the detective assigned to the case.
A foreign dignitary is guarded by Laura and Jake, and the job entails fending off protesters and dealing with death threats.
A dormant serial killer is suspected of resurfacing as Valentine's Day takes a deadly turn. Meanwhile, secrets of a romantic nature fill the squad room.
The city's leading sports surgeon is killed and evidence points to members of a men's rights group. Meanwhile, Billy and Meredith progress to the next step of their relationship.
Laura's life is in danger, so she fights to survive and defeat a killer as the murder case of perfume mogul Michael Dunham takes a shocking turn.
A perfume mogul is killed in a savage manner and the investigation yields no prime suspect. Meanwhile, Laura and Jake are at odds when they try to define the current state of their relationship.
morelessThe team track a killer involved in an urban treasure hunt, and it leads them to places of extremes, including grungy rooftops and lavish music halls. While on the case, Laura ponders the new manifestations of modern love.
morelessAn undercover cop is exposed and killed, so the team investigate his homicide and are targeted in the process, forcing them to alter their approach.
The body of a pregnant woman is found on the side of the road while the team is pursuing an international smuggling ring, but they soon discover something surprising about the goods being trafficked.
morelessA gym owner is killed when he's trapped in his own sauna, so the team investigate the world of fitness extremists and uncover an unanticipated threat.
A media mogul's wife is driven off of a main highway, and the investigation unearths a secret in an old—and supposedly closed—case.
Two convicted killers flee a maximum security prison and Laura's team help look for them, but others doubt her team's loyalties because one of the escaped killers is their former captain.
A technology whiz is killed in a supposedly secure building, and his valuable ideas are in danger of being stolen if the police don't solve the case quickly.
When a boy is kidnapped from his Tribeca family, Laura and team are thrust into a high-stakes race against time. They must uncover a host of family secrets in order to save the boy.
morelessIn the first-season finale as Jake lies in critical condition, Laura and the team hunt his shooter, an assailant armed with a high-tech new weapon.
A young filmmaker is murdered, and an inexperienced detective causes problems with the investigation as Laura's team search for the killer.