Bellamy and Sheriff Fred fear that Caleb may have returned to Arcadia when they hear reports that someone is living in his old hunting shack. At the same time, Bellamy struggles with the knowledge that he is one of the returned and has difficulty following the orders of his mysterious boss. Meanwhile, Janine tries to save her marriage to Pastor Tom by moving back home; and Margaret Langston is none too happy to learn what has become of the family business.moreless
Ethan avoids Emma as she seeks to learn what really happened on the reservation. Thayer begins to doubt Alec's alibi. Kristin grows suspicious of Ted's story about Justin's mother.
Family tensions arise when Ethan travels to his father's home to hide from the police. Emma must lie in the aftermath of Ethan's crime.
Ethan gets into trouble when he seeks information about a tattoo. Laurel ignores her parents' wishes and continues to see Justin.
Jane wants to defend a man who is thought to be crazy, and the case could put her job at risk. Teri finds herself involved in a lawsuit with a childhood friend.moreless