Kelsey has four children: son Jude, born 28 August 2004 via surrogate birth, daughter, Spencer Grammer, born October 9, 1983, with Doreen Alderman, daughter Greer, born 1992, with Barrie Buckner and daughter Mason Olivia Grammer, who was delivered by a surrogate mother on October 24, 2001 and weighed in at 8 pounds, 5 ounces. In memory of his sister who was raped and murdered, he named his daughter Spencer Karen. (Karen was his sister's first name). His son was named after his maternal grandfather, Gordon Cranmer, who helped raise him and his sister. He passed away when Kelsey was 11.