In 1989, after meeting on the set of Loving, Lisa began dating hockey player turned actor James Burns. They became engaged later that year but never married, Lisa broke off the engagement saying that she needed "space."
In 1991, Lisa was romantically linked to one of the members of the legendary band ZZ Top. That same year she also dated Another World hunk, Tom Eplin, for a very short time.
Married Brad Guice on June 10th 1995.