This episode takes place three years after the previous one, in which the killer of Judge Natalie Rodman escaped justice.
The victim: Trent McAllister, the killer: Lexi Moore.
Trent is the owner of a company that specializes in high end repossessions while Lexi is a friend to Thomas Anderson, Trent's estranged grandson. Trent's body is found next to a helicopter having by being caught in the rear rotor. The team reunites to pursue both the previously unsolved and current homicides.
Lucifer is intrigued when Chloe becomes interested in the murder of a movie actor's son. Meanwhile, Amenadiel and Maze both continue their efforts to get Lucifer to return to Hell.
A police program that monitors suspicious behavior is introduced and Vega tries to get Akeela's help in landing Dash a position as the program's analyst. Meanwhile, Vega and Dash suspect Arthur is up to something.moreless
Desperate to shake her geeky girl high school persona, Dr. Emily Owens couldn't be happier to star work as an intern at Denver Memorial Hospital. Much to her dismay, she discovers that her new workplace and her old high school environment have much more in common than she originally thought.moreless
One year after their battle with the Leviathans, Sam finally finds his brother Dean, who reveals what happened to him and Castiel in Purgatory. They soon reunite with the prophet Kevin and learn about another Word of God... and an unbelievable opportunity.moreless
Meg summons Sam and Dean when Castiel wakes up. However, the brothers have other problems on their hands when they get word of a teenager who has been struck by lightning and become a prophet, and may hold the key to defeating the Leviathans.moreless
A wrongly convicted Southern chef hires Shawn and Gus to find the real thief after the Innocence Project frees him from prison.
A girl receives a life-size doll that looks exactly like her and strange things start happening to her.