Matthew Lillard is one of the truly underrated actors of his generation. Often typecast as the twitchy sidekick or insane friend (or both!), when he's allowed to shine on his own, Lillard shows not only a great ability for comedy, but also a great ability to play dark and creepy -- he is able to showcase both of these abilities in the 2001 remake Thir13en Ghosts as ghost hunter Dennis Rafkin. Although most people wouldn't consider a cheesy horror movie to be the place to make a name for oneself, Lillard shows a range of emotion in this one film he's seldom been able to relay in his major endeavors. Lillard often plays a character that fans love to hate, but in his portrayal of a psychic tormented by his powers, he allows his fans to see that he's more than just a jumpy face. On the flipside of that coin, we've got Lillard's performance in the dark college comedy The Curve, which showed a darker side to Michael Vartan and Keri Russell as well. Lillard was downright creepy in this film, which was accentuated by the crew's continuance on focussing the camera on facial shots.
If any doubt existed in my mind to Matthew's talents, that was erased after having seen him in the Scooby Doo movies. Although not a particular fan of the films (they're not bad, just not my taste), Lillard's take on Shaggy was amazing. As a fan of the series throughout my childhood years, I was amazed at how close Lillard came to capturing the character. Anyone who can do that as well as play the creepily dark Tim and the tragically tortured Rafkin definitely deserves a second look. Unfortunately, Matthew seems relegated to films that focus on his comedic timing rather than his acting skills.