While Joe and Cisco take a road trip to Starling City to find evidence confirming Harrison's guilt, Flash deals with Everyman, a metahuman who can take the shape of anyone he touches.
King and Maxwell investigate the circumstances surrounding Agent Carter's suspension but find clues involving Carter's most recent case. King discloses the mistake that led to his downfall from the Secret Service.
A consultant is brought in to evaluate everyone's effectiveness as detectives, but their alleged misdeeds are matched only by the quirkiness of the consultant.
Sam and Dean take on a case with Castiel, who has decided to become a hunter. However, they discover that the murder is only the latest in a string of cartoon deaths.
Some interesting facts are unveiled during a father/daughter bike ride. Abby discovers her father's secret obsession with Wakefield, while Henry and Trish have an eventful wedding rehearsal.