Frank comes to the hospital looking for Kevin and is immediately corralled by two male nurses acting on Karen's orders. Though Rafe accuses him of lying to obtain another soul, James persists with his claim that Ed is the young man's father. Livvie confesses her crime to Rachel during a visit to her institutionalized mother. As Rebecca lights her candle, Kevin suddenly fades away into thin air. Later, Lucy comes by in search of her husband but finds only his briefcase and his car. Rafe begins to wonder if James' story about Ed could be true. Livvie tearfully explains to Rachel how everyone has been questioning her sanity just because she's trying to save the world from the forces of evil. Alison tells Lucy how Kevin disappeared while she was packing up candles in the back room. After having Frank restrained in a padded room on the psych ward, Karen sadly informs her boyfriend why his story about an "allergic" reaction to a candle doesn't ring true. Ed finally admits to Rafe how he fell in love with and impregnated the young man's mother but passed away before they could marry. Lucy panics to find blood all over Alison's apron. Ed warns his son that he'll be lost forever if he sells his soul but Rafe turns a deaf ear to the good advice.