This episode was...tolerable, mildly at best. Even there I am being generous. The more I think about this episode and watching it over again, the more I just didn't like it.moreless
10
"Perfect"
This episode was...tolerable, mildly at best. Even there I am being generous. The more I think about this episode and watching it over again, the more I just didn't like it. Too many things in this episode was either recycled again or just plan odd in the telling of the writers. And I have a bone to pick on the writers and their ever increasingly odd concepts on marriage. Secondly, what's up with the title (Bad Boys, Bad Boys, Whatcha Gonna Do), no one was actually bad in this episode and saw no relevance. Let's break it down...
Eric and Annie: For Eric (Stephen Collins) and Annie (Catherine Hicks) in this episode they once again team up in helping a pregnant Leanne who is in her teens, to help put her baby up for adoption. She has no one in her life after her mom kicked her out of her house and the baby's father's parents forbid him to see her. She decides it's the best thing to do for her baby up until the last moment when she goes into labor and changes her mind. As for this storyline, I felt absolutely nothing for it. It's not because she wasn't a good actress or the storyline was really that bad (although there were quite a few errors), it's just that the writers have done this teen pregnancy storyline so many times over the years that's it's just now repetitive and boring. You can only tell the same story so many times that the viewers get bored. Please writers, no more. We've had enough over this issue.
This has been a constant sour of the writers for this series in recent seasons as they continue to revisit issues they've done a dozen times already (teen pregnancy, drugs, alcohol abuse, etc.) Move on to something else that the series has not yet explored. Another problem I had with the storyline was the ending when the parents of each child's side came together and proclaimed at the idea that they should get married, once again a ridiculous input by the writers. It was an easy out and a easy closure of a storyline where in real life would hardly be the case.
At this point in the episode Charlie and Leanne (Amanda Fuller) were just reunited while she's giving birth to their child after spending much of her pregnancy apart from Charlie, no thanks to his parents and the fact that Leanne's mom kicked her out of the house. Now, as the two have barely reunited, Charlie's parents now want them to get married after having one well-meaning conversation with Eric and Annie? Even they are not that good. It was just very unrealistic and very hard not see that, even by 7th Heaven standards. Just because you have a baby doesn't mean you automatically get married if you're a teenage couple in circumstances like these. Life doesn't work like that, and this is not the year 1952 writers!
As for Lucy counseling the adoptive parents, I'm sure it was meant to be funny, but it probably came off a little offensive to many people who are adopting a child or considering to adopt, as both adoptive couples in this episode that Lucy interviewed were particularly self-involved and self-righteous in their ridiculous questions and explanations to Lucy over their intentions on adopting a baby. One couple (Marcus and Bernadette) wants to know that their soon-to-be adoptive baby is a genius and not some dumb crack baby with mental illness, and the other couple (Sunny and Jim) wants the baby to work around their schedule as they have a huge restaurant business to maintain---Oh, and Jim doesn't want his wife to mess with her figure by getting pregnant. There is no question that there are probably people out there like that in the adoption process arena, but it would've been better if at least one of the couples had been satisfactory. Most adoptive parents are well meaning childless couples who just want to be parents to baby that's in need under circumstances. You would think that would be the case here since Brenda Hampton is an adoptive parent herself. It was quite shocking on how this part of the storyline was badly mishandled.
Simon and Justin: Simon (David Gallagher) is obviously the most interesting character of everyone this season thus far and yet his storyline in this episode was way too short and we barely saw him. It was great to see how Justin (Joey Gray) was doing after a year has passed of the accident. It's great that's he's not blaming Simon anymore for his little brother's problem of drugs and what happened that night of the accident. There was one little problem though---maybe it was the wording in the script that made it sound off, but for Justin to say that Simon accidently killing his pot-smoking brother brought his family closer together was kind fo weird. That was quite inappropriate for him to say that only after a year his little brother is dead, no matter what the circumstances are. Either that or Dr. Gibson is a miracle worker. That could possibly be so as he got to the route of Simon's sex and school problems after only ONE session. (That was something I forgot to add in my review for last week.)
Besides all of that it does seem like Simon is leaving the family to go back to college and probably won't appear for a few episodes.
Harry and Ruthie: This was also a confusing storyline. It was only last week that we were introduced to Harry (Aaron Carter) who was just getting started to charm Ruthie on, and now this week he wants to break up with her? Wait, when were they even together? They never went out on a date (at least not on screen) and the only kiss we ever saw was Harry giving her one on the cheek last week, and she even rejected it! I really must be missing something here.
Also, another bone that needs to be picked in this storyline is, once again, this fascination of the writers having on the concept marriage in this series. Harry confesses to Eric that he wants to get married to this other girl that's in foster care with him so he can leave the system and have a family of his own. First of all, he's 16 years old! Harry is living in the U.S. and is not able to get married, especially when the government has custody of you. This really makes me questions the writers sanity. Plus, most kids I know that age are not thinking about marriage, at least where I'm from.
As for the sick bird storyline involving Ruthie finding a bird in the backyard; is that the best we can do for Ruthie and Martin (Tyler Hoechlin) and Kevin (George Stults) in this episode? Out of all the more better things and interesting storylines these characters could be doing this week, it's this? Writers, you really are boring these characters (and probably the actors) in these dumb storylines. Please, give each of these characters more of a life in upcoming episodes.
Overall, this episode just didn't do it for me. This is definately the weakest episode so far this season by far. Taking a look at next week I'm not too sure how this is gonna turn out either with the Vote episode. Because once you mix politics and social issues into 7th Heaven (i.e Brenda Hampton), things turn out bad and very offensive as many episodes have done in recent seasons. I rather the show continue to focus on inner family issues like in the last 3 episodes and not go political. Anyway, till next week! Chow!
Grade: **4 out of 10**
Rants and Bits:
*Seriously, what kind of opening scene was that with the camera dancing along with Simon? Seriously, all that jumping around gave me a headache cameraman! Never do that again!
*Why was this episode titled Bad Boys, Bad Boys, Whatcha Gonna Do? I absolutely saw no relevance of the title to anything seen in this episode.
*Sam and David are just...whatever. That one twin completely butchered that "glorious food" line. I really cringed at that point. And why are they answering the phone and telling everyone what happened to Leanne and Charlie? That was a bad way to end the episode with bad twin actors.
*Does Aaron Carter (Harry) have a lisps problem? He seemed to have one when he was talking a lot in this episode. I didn't notice it too much in the last episode.
*I personally know that a lot scenes in this episode were cut, particularly the scenes involving Lucy counseling her teen sex group. Who in the world would edit that out and keep in the boring Ruthie storyline of the sick bird? That was just bad editting.moreless