Martin, Mac, Jane and Margaret meet for the first time and trouble arises. Both guys like Jane, while Jane has only eyes for Martin. Unfortunately trouble starts when Martin meets Sandy at the church to pick up Aaron and asks if they're free to see other people. Sandy sees the girls and Mac and realizes that Martin was going to take Aaron on a double date.
Sandy ends up taking care of her son while explaining to Lucy's girls the harsh realities of raising a baby by herself.
Martin and Mac both try to compete for Jane's hand, with Mac suggesting he and the girls get an apartment together. Things cool down really fast for Martin when Margaret deliberately tells the guys that Jane is married. Martin tries to get back with Sandy only to find out she's not interested in being the rebound, especially when she know Martin only came because of Jane being married.