At the very beginning George Reeves gives a narration that tells the story about Jimmy Olsen receiving an invitation to spend the summer on Moose Island, which was off the coast of Maine with his Aunt Louisa and his cousin Chris. When we see the scene at the house you can see the fake background and the shadow of Aunt Louisa (Sara Padden) coming out the door to greet Jimmy. His cousin Chris (Jimmy Ogg) seems deliberately unfriendly. Through Reeves narration we learn of Alice (Allene Roberts), a pretty house maid who cannot hear or speak. Jim is escorted into in his uncles room during his stay. Although he has been dead for 20 years, Aunt Louisa kept it as if Jimmy's uncle was still alive.
Jim's uncle drowned 20 years earlier and the light house on Moose Island had been abandoned ever since the tragedy. Jim is exploring the shore when he heard the Signature Line of the episode; Help me I'm drowning. Jim runs around looking for the voice when Mack (William Challee) startled him. Mack thought that Jim was Chris at first and asked Jim to help him store stuff before a storm hits. When Mack finally noticed that Olsen was not Chris he ordered Jim to go home and get Chris.
Chris does not like Jimmy staying with them and accuses him of spying. Aunt Louisa explains that Chris has a bad temper and does not like anyone near the Lighthouse. Later that night Jim noticed a light on in the lighthouse so he goes to investigate. While trying to open the lighthouse door, Chris followed Jimmy and threw a dagger at the door. When Jim tried to tell Chris he is a reporter and this haunted lighthouse would make a great story, Chris threatens Jim and orders him to go back home and go to bed.
When Jim gets to his room he notices a note that reads "In Terrible Trouble. Wont You Come? Aunt Louisa". Jim hurries to his Aunt's room when Alice comes up behind him and motions that she wants Jim to follow her. When the two go through the hall and out the door from the kitchen, Aunt Louisa lights a lamb with a match and yells Where do you two think you are going? Sara Padden recited this line with such force that it makes you jump and also adds to the macabre of the story. Jimmy tries to calm her down by telling her he was worried and they were going out to look for her. Aunt Louisa said in a stern voice that Alice should have known better than that. Alice and Jim went back to their rooms and back to bed.
Finally in the next scene almost half way through the episode, Jimmy calls Clark at the Daily Planet to ask him to come to Moose Island. While on the phone Jimmy hears the voice again crying for help. The fearful look on Jack Larson's face is quite impressive. Jack makes it look like his eyes are going to bulge right out of their sockets.
Clark changes into Superman and flies off to Moose Island. Gary Grossman points out a blooper in this scene; when Superman lands at Moose Island the sound effects of him flying were still running.
Clark meets Jimmy at his Aunt Louisa's house and asked him why Jim did not meet him at the Mainland? Jimmy replied by saying his aunt and Chris took the boat and the telephone lines were shut down. Jimmy also made a comment to Clark by saying he does not know if he is coming or going in this crazy town. Jimmy then shows Clark the island and takes him to a cave.
Clark asks Jimmy to show him the invitation and the note Aunt Louisa wrote him. Clark then asks Jimmy to get her write out a recipe or something so he can compare hand writings. Jimmy goes back to the house while Clark changes back to Superman and flies onto a Coast Guard Ship. Superman is greeted by a Lieutenant played by Stephen Carr. Stephen Carr was the brother of Tommy Carr, who directed this episode. Stephen was also the voice director for the first two seasons of Superman.
Superman informed the Lieutenant that he must go to Moose Island to investigate some strange activity that is taking place. Meanwhile Jimmy gets a recipe for Blueberry pie and Alice gives him another strange note that reads "Alice will bring you to me late tonight. Be careful they do not hear you. They are desperate people. Aunt Louisa".
After reading this Jimmy exits through a window to seek out Mr. Kent. He goes back to the cave where they last saw each other, but Jimmy did not notice that Chris and Mack saw him and followed him into the cave. The two grab Jimmy, knock him out and then lower a steel bar so that when the tide comes in, the rising water will drown him. Jimmy staggers to get up and yells for Mr. Kent and then we see the waves rushing onto the island and into the cave. The signature voice cries "Help I'm drowning" is heard from again and Jimmy collapses.
Chris and Mack are back at the house telling how the tide will completely cover Jimmy and they hear the sound of the Coast Guard boat heading towards the lighthouse. Chris grabs a rifle that is hanging on a wall and both men rush towards the lighthouse. On the boat Superman is guiding the Lieutenant through the smog when he sees Mack with the rifle and also notices that Jim is in trouble. Superman leaps off the boat flies to the cave, bends the cage bars and he gets Jimmy out of danger. Gary Grossman talks about this scene on how the bars would not move, so it took a long time to film this scene. It has been reported that Jack Larson caught a bad cold from being in the cold water for a long time.
After Superman got Jimmy out of the cave he jumped up to confront Mack. Mack takes out a knife to stab Superman only to get his dagger bent. Then he picked up a large rock to throw at Superman but Superman moved out of the way and Mack went over the cliff. After this Superman looks at the notes and recipe Jimmy brought with him and The Man of Steel begins to unravel the mystery. Jimmy's real Aunt Louisa is in the lighthouse. Chris and Mack are smuggling contraband into the lighthouse using the cave as an entrance.
The end scene we see Jimmy's real Aunt Louisa (Effie Laird) waking through the door holding a pistol pointed at the fake Aunt Louisa. We find out that her name is Mrs. Carmody and she was the housekeeper. When Jimmy's real cousin Chris went off to the Service, Mrs. Carmodys son Chris came to live with them. A humorous bit of dialogue comes up when Clark Kent comes into the house and Aunt Louisa notices that he looks a lot like Superman but before she utters Clark Kents other identity Clark moves real quick away from her and towards the Lieutenant who is holding a gun at Chris. Clark tells the Lieutenant that there are silk, leather, English china and silverware in the lighthouse. The cries for help come again and we find out it is Peter the parrot, who wants to be home and fed. This was a nice piece to chuckle at after a tense drama.
If you like mystery suspense and drama this is the perfect episode to watch. This was the second installment in the first season but this was the set up for more to follow in this season. I hope you enjoy this show and if you have already seen it in the past I am confident that you will never get tired of watching it in the future.





