Much to his annoyance, Judge Condon wife Grace has a boyfriend named Wally Donaldson. Condon tries to prove that he is all wrong for her. He invites Wally for a glass of wine, which he tells him, was purchased on Grace's Spanish Honeymoon. After Wally drinks the wine, Condon tells him it is poisoned when, in fact, it is not. Wally panics and kills Condon. When Grace appears, Wally tells her about the wine. Grace reveals, she has never had a honeymoon or been to Spain.