The one survivor of the Roanoke House massacre stands trial for murder, and must face Lana Winters in a one-on-one interview.
A trio of fans of the series make a pilgrimage to the Shaker House... during the Blood Moon. Meanwhile, Audrey and Lee try to find Monet and the camera, and Dylan's rescue proves short-lived.
While Audrey, Monet, and Lee try to escape the Polk farm, Shelby and Dominic discover that there's no escape from the house.
When Rory disappears, the house occupants begin to suspect something is wrong. Meanwhile, Agnes pays Sidney a surprise visit, while Lee, Audrey,and Monet decide to check out the secret tunnel beneath the house.
Months after the first successful season of My Roanoke Nightmare, producer Sidney James decides to return to the house and film a second season, bringing the reenactment actors and the people they played... during the Blood Moon.
The Millers try to escape the house and a previous owner helps them. Meanwhile, Lee comes looking for her daughter, and the Polks look for a meal.
The Millers meet the house's previous owner, and he tells them the history of the place. Meanwhile, Scathach summons Matt to collect the payment promised her by Cricket, and Tomasyn captures Cricket.
The secrets of Roanoke begin to reveal themselves, thanks to a psychic named Cricket who arrives when the search for Flora turns up nothing.
The mysterious events at the farmhouse continue. Meanwhile, Lee takes extreme steps to get her daughter Flora back, only to lose her to a ghostly presence.
After Shelby and Matt Miller are attacked by a street gang in LA and Shelby miscarries, they move to a quiet farmhouse in North Carolina. However, the interracial couple soon discover that their problems have only begun.