Jude faces another threat to her life when a new inmate joins Briarcliff. Meanwhile, Grace turns increasingly distracted as her obsession with her alien abductors grows.
Lana receives startling news from Mary Eunice. Meanwhile, Arden sets out to learn what happened to Grace and Monsignor Howard takes on a true believer.
While Howard makes a deal with Arden that he may live to regret, a young girl is dropped off at Briarcliff. Meanwhile, the true identity of Bloody Face is revealed.
Bloody Mask's identity is revealed after Kit makes a confession. Meanwhile, Sister Jude learns about Arden's past and brings in a Nazi hunter to get the proof she needs to deal with the doctor and the threat he poses to her control.
While Kit learns the real reason that Grace is in Briarcliff, Arden must cope with a patient who claims to be Anne Frank... and can reveal his twisted past.
Kit, Grace, and Shelley plan to use a storm as a distraction to escape. Meanwhile, Sister Jude faces a ghost from her past and Arden begins to lose his nerve, while Lana finds an ally in Dr. Thredson.