wasn't pleased.
Short - VERY very brief - opinions below.
Eliminated Boys: Joe Munoz & Tyler Grady
Um, what the hell? Joe and Tyler have a distinct uniqueness to them; Joe, as Seacrest said, always smiling, always positive and he looked like a bright bulb that stood out. He had an aura when he was performing his final. I just smiled at how he took it so well, and sang his song, radiating a positivity that I don't think any of the other guys have (probably because of the fact he's much much younger). And Tyler, we all know his 70s rocker style set him out apart from everyone else. Neither were bad; I think Joe was definitely in the top 5, maybe top 3 of the boys' performances. Both should've stayed on.
Who I think should've been eliminated: Alex Lambert, Tim Urban
Who I liked the best: Lee DeWyse, Casey James
Eliminated Girls: Janell Wheeler & Ashley Rodriguez
I kinda wanted Janell to stay, but I think the only basis I have is that I think she's really cute. Brightening and really pretty. (Don't agree? Look. http://www.jpsingian.com/JANELL.jpg) That makes her marketable, and it's not like she has a bad voice. She doesn't. Let's just say there were worse. Singing What About Love (too big) and Love Story (unsuitable) for her final two performances may have been what cost her. And about Ashley, I think she had 'upside'. She might've not blown it out of the park on Tuesday, but she has potential. She could've been really good - as in, final 10 really good - and Tuesday was only a mis-step. The others don't nearly have the same potential as she does. I liked her since her first audition.
Who I think should've been eliminated: Haeley Vaughn, Paige Miles (You'll probably disagree with that one)
Who I liked the best: Honestly, no one.
Joe's exit bugs me the most. In terms of intangibles, he's so far ahead of Alex and Tim. The camera constantly went back to Tim, you obviously know he thinks he shouldn't have gone through either.
On Alison Iraheta: Um, what happened after the song? Did she lose her voice from singing or has she lost the ability to talk without emitting raspyness from her voice? That was weird. I don't think Ryan knew at all what she was trying to say (nor did anyone else).
On Kris Allen: The guy looks excellent. Looks like a champion. Didn't love his performance, but I liked it.
Also really really good that the economy has improved and they could do an Idol Gives Back this year.
~ (Displeased)moreless
Episode Summary
EDIT
During the first live results show of the season, four semifinalists - two girls and two boys - will be eliminated from the competition and sent home. Tune in to see if your favorites made the cut when the first four contestants are sent home after America's vote is revealed.moreless
Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions
See All-
TRIVIA (0)
ADD TRIVIA- ADD TRIVIA from this episode.
-
QUOTES (0)
ADD QUOTES- ADD QUOTES from this episode.
-
NOTES (0)
ADD NOTES- ADD NOTES from this episode.
-
ALLUSIONS (0)
ADD ALLUSIONS- ADD ALLUSIONS from this episode.
-
No car
05/27/121
-
Official Thread For The Finale
05/27/123
-
Official Thread For The Top 7 Perform Again & Results Show
04/18/121
-
What's the name of the song?
04/13/125
-
Official Thread For The Top 8 Perform & Results Show
04/13/122
Related Shows
-
-
tv
Can You Duet -
-
-
Season 9 Episodes
See AllEp 43
And The Winner Is............
Ep 42
Crystal Bowersox Vs Lee De...
Ep 41
Find Out Who Makes It To T...
Ep 40
The Top 3 Take The Stage Live
Ep 39
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 38
The Four Finalists Take Th...
Ep 37
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 36
The Five Finalists Take Th...
Ep 35
The Top 6 Becomes A Top 5
Ep 34
The Top Six Finalists Perform
Ep 33
Idol Gives Back Part 2, & ...
Ep 32
The Seven Finalists Take T...
Ep 31
This Week, Due To Last Wee...
Ep 30
After The Judge's' Save Wa...
Ep 29
Find Out Who Stays And Who...
Ep 28
The Top 9 FinalistsTake Th...
Ep 27
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 26
The Top 10 Take The Stage ...
Ep 25
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 24
The Top 11 Finalists Take ...
Ep 23
One Of The Top 12 Must Go ...
Ep 22
The Top 12 Finalists Perfo...
Ep 21
4 Semi-Finalists Eliminate...
Ep 20
Top 8 Guys Perform Live
Ep 19
Top 8 Girls Perform Live
Ep 18
America Says Goodbye To Fo...
more
-
RyanSeacrest EDITOR
User Score: 5312
-
pedroman01
User Score: 1173
-
krazy4crack
User Score: 396
-
UncleRegis
User Score: 282
-
dude6363
User Score: 269
-
HILOLAK
User Score: 147
-
DM655
User Score: 108
-
tvFANatic20
User Score: 99
-
mstheresa1969
User Score: 88
-
agent_0042
User Score: 75
More
Less
