Season 1- Didn't watch, but probably Kelly if I would have
Season 2- NO WAY. I really liked Clay, and Ruben I never understood. He was a really boring singer honestly.
Season 3- NO WAY TIMES ONE MILLION! I was a HUGE Jennifer Hudson fan (Still am), and I never saw the appeal at all.
Season 4- Sort of. I LOVED Vonzell, and when she didn't make the finale I wanted Bo. However, I would buy a Carrie CD before a Bo CD. I do hate country though.
Season 5- NO WAY TIMES INFINITY! I will never, ever , ever, ever understand the appeal. EVER! I thought he was TERRIBLE!!!! I like Chris at the time (Not so much now though) and I really like Kat, and Elliott was very talented. How did Taylor beat them?
Season 6-Absolutely. The first season that I liked the winner and supported the winner. I didn't like Blake, and even Melinda bugged me a little bit. I like that Jordin won.
Season 7- Sort of. Between the Davids, absolutely. But I liked Carly and Jason so much, that I didn't like Cook for the entire season until the end. Looking back though, DC was very good.