Now Simon has left the show there are no more harsh judgments and for me part of the fun was seeing losers be shot down prefarably with an atombomb of a destroying comment. A bit like Wiley Coyote being shot down in his attempts to catch the illussive Roadrunner.
I know J-Lo can be a beeatch but judging on American Idol is part of a charm offensive to boost her carreer that's in the dumps, so she won't step up. Randy's nastiest and only comment is "it was pitchy..."
Leaves us with Steven Tyler whose only Achilles' heel are beautiful women, so he's the number one candidate for the job!!!