Let me just say first off that the reason I didn't rate this lower was because this was their first performance, and nerves may have gotten in the way. But even then, based on some of these people's performances, it'll be tough to understand how the hell they got through.
I'll start with the good. Casey James probably did the best performance. His was pretty low-key, but he hit just about all of his notes and put on a good performance, PLUS he's a great musician. Andrew Garcia, despite what the judges said, did a good performance, even if it wasn't as poweful as his audition or Hollywood week. In comparison to the rest of the guys, he was great. John Park showed he can sing, although they sort of chastised him too for being boring (which I agree with).
However, the rest were just mediocre and worse. The judges seemed to enjoy Aaron Kelly and the song he did, but I heard something completely different. He had a thin voice that only could be seen as impressive because of the loud and high notes he tried to hit. But his voice was shaky and he seemed uncomfortable. Same with Alex Lambert, who I was looking forward to hearing but was ultimately disappointed with. I can't even begin to talk about how bad Tim Urban and Jermaine Sellers were.. It was just a disappointing night.
Once again, I rarely agreed with the judges. Oh well. Hopefully next week, all the guys can step it up because the girls completely dominated.moreless
Episode Summary
EDIT
The Top 12 male semifinalists sing their hearts out live for America and the American Idol judges. After the performances, it is up to America to vote. Performing Tonight Are: Aaron Kelly Alex Lambert Andrew Garcia Casey James Jermaine Sellers Joe Muoz John Park Lee Dewyze Michael Lynche Tim Urban Todrick Hall Tyler Gradymoreless
Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions
See All-
TRIVIA (2)
ADD TRIVIA-
Human Target is pre-empted tonight.
-
This is a 2 hour episode.
-
-
QUOTES (0)
ADD QUOTES- ADD QUOTES from this episode.
-
NOTES (1)
ADD NOTES-
Song choices are: Aaron Kelly - Here Comes Goodbye Alex Lambert - Wonderful World Andrew Garcia - Sugar We're Going Down Casey James - Heaven Jermaine Sellers - Get Here Joe Muñoz - You And I Both John Park - God Bless The Child Lee Dewyze - Chasing Cars Michael Lynche - This Love Tim Urban - Apologize Todrick Hall - Since You've Been Gone Tyler Grady - American Woman
-
-
ALLUSIONS (0)
ADD ALLUSIONS- ADD ALLUSIONS from this episode.
-
No car
05/27/121
-
Official Thread For The Finale
05/27/123
-
Official Thread For The Top 7 Perform Again & Results Show
04/18/121
-
What's the name of the song?
04/13/125
-
Official Thread For The Top 8 Perform & Results Show
04/13/122
Related Shows
-
-
tv
Can You Duet -
-
-
Season 9 Episodes
See AllEp 43
And The Winner Is............
Ep 42
Crystal Bowersox Vs Lee De...
Ep 41
Find Out Who Makes It To T...
Ep 40
The Top 3 Take The Stage Live
Ep 39
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 38
The Four Finalists Take Th...
Ep 37
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 36
The Five Finalists Take Th...
Ep 35
The Top 6 Becomes A Top 5
Ep 34
The Top Six Finalists Perform
Ep 33
Idol Gives Back Part 2, & ...
Ep 32
The Seven Finalists Take T...
Ep 31
This Week, Due To Last Wee...
Ep 30
After The Judge's' Save Wa...
Ep 29
Find Out Who Stays And Who...
Ep 28
The Top 9 FinalistsTake Th...
Ep 27
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 26
The Top 10 Take The Stage ...
Ep 25
Find Out Who Is The Next F...
Ep 24
The Top 11 Finalists Take ...
Ep 23
One Of The Top 12 Must Go ...
Ep 22
The Top 12 Finalists Perfo...
Ep 21
4 Semi-Finalists Eliminate...
Ep 20
Top 8 Guys Perform Live
Ep 19
Top 8 Girls Perform Live
Ep 18
America Says Goodbye To Fo...
more
-
RyanSeacrest EDITOR
User Score: 5312
-
pedroman01
User Score: 1173
-
krazy4crack
User Score: 396
-
UncleRegis
User Score: 282
-
dude6363
User Score: 269
-
HILOLAK
User Score: 147
-
DM655
User Score: 108
-
tvFANatic20
User Score: 99
-
mstheresa1969
User Score: 88
-
agent_0042
User Score: 75
More
Less
