We're moving Forums to the Community pages. Click here for more information and updates.

American Idol

Season 6 Episode 19

Top 12 Finalists To Be Revealed

0
Aired Wednesday 8:00 PM Mar 08, 2007 on FOX
7.3
out of 10
User Rating
56 votes
18

EPISODE REVIEWS
By TV.com Users

Episode Summary

EDIT
Top 12 Finalists To Be Revealed
AIRED:

In the most dramatic results show of the season thus far, four more semifinalists two boys and two girls will go home, leaving the Top 12 finalists to vie for the American Idol crown. The viewers' choices for the Top 12 will be revealed tonight live.

moreless
Friday
No results found.
Saturday
No results found.
Sunday
No results found.
SUBMIT REVIEW
  • So WROOOOOOOONG!

    4.6
    How come a guy that can't even sing beat up an amazing female singer that have nothing but a wonderful voice???



    This show is so wrong right now. Of course, we all thank for Kelly Clarkson, even for Carrie underwood... but don't tell me the american idol 2007 will be someone that wins over popularity, not because he actually sings!
  • Very disapointed!

    6.7
    Me and my wife watch American Idol, and of course we have our favorites and know that some will leave before others. It's all the same. However, the first two to go were expected. They were ok singers and people but they disn't make it. But when the brought down the last 2 guy's and last two girls, the two who made it should have gone and the two who were kick off should have stay'd. I know they say that america votes them off and I can understand how people might have thought they got a lot of votes so i won't vote n stuff, but come on now. Is it that America really voted them off or is American Idol making it pivitol for rating's. Hummm. I guess we'll never know. I'm not saying it's a set up or anything. I guess if you like someone, don't count on everyone else who likes them to vote for them. I was just disapointed. I'll still watch, but I'm not happy. :)moreless
  • Sorry, posted double by mistake.

    6.5
    Ok, yes we got some talent in this top 12, there's Stephanie, LaKisha, Melinda, what's his name and who's that guy...



    Antonella finally left, since she didn't really deserve to stay.



    Jared's departure didn't really shocked me, he didn't make much an impression on me.



    But two results left me in shock.



    First of all: Haley vs. Sabrina, they fight for one place, Haley wins.

    Then one question popped in my mind, who the hell is this girl? We've sent home a girl who, in my opinion, was one of the top vocalists to keep an absolutely forgetable "singer".

    Something's wrong.



    Now, the episode ends with Sanjaya vs. Sundance, pfff it's clear, the place belongs to Sundance for sure.

    Then Ryan talks, and it appears America thinks long hair should keep you under the spotlight.

    At first I thought it was a joke, then Sundance performed, the tape started and the little Sanjaya takes his place on the last seat who should have been filled by... well... someone else! Anyone else! What did Sanjaya do to deserve to stay? No charisma, no passion, no real feel, no voice... What kept him in? The freaking hula?

    Something's very wrongmoreless
  • Something's wrong. Something's very wrong.

    6.5
    Ok, yes we got some talent in this top 12, there's Stephanie, LaKisha, Melinda, what's his name and who's that guy...



    Antonella finally left, since she didn't really deserve to stay.



    Jared's departure didn't really shocked me, he didn't make much an impression on me.



    But two results left me in shock.



    First of all: Haley vs. Sabrina, they fight for one place, Haley wins.

    Then one question popped in my mind, who the hell is this girl? We've sent home a girl who, in my opinion, was one of the top vocalists to keep an absolutely forgetable "singer".

    Something's wrong.



    Now, the episode ends with Sanjaya vs. Sundance, pfff it's clear, the place belongs to Sundance for sure.

    Then Ryan talks, and it appears America thinks long hair should keep you under the spotlight.

    At first I thought it was a joke, then Sundance performed, the tape started and the little Sanjaya takes his place on the last seat who should have been filled by... well... someone else! Anyone else! What did Sanjaya do to deserve to stay? No charisma, no passion, no real feel, no voice... What kept him in? The freaking hula?

    Something's very wrongmoreless
  • A couple of stunning upsets.

    8.0
    Poor Jared! Didn’t see that coming. His last performance showed a lack of confidence, but then he belted out a killer rendition of it on exit and if he had sung it that way before, I'm certain he would not have been going home.



    Poor Antonella! She fell victim to a fate that took on a life of its own. Don’t hate her because she’s beautiful! I think the press done her in. The picture of her on the beach with her friends was no big deal—that’s just kids doing kid things. But when her face got superimposed on naked bodies by media people out for a fast buck, the ball got rolling. And that photo of her in American Beauty-style petals is what doomed her. It looked like she deliberately posed for that to take advantage of the media attention, but that could have been photoshopped, too. I think the public didn’t feel it was a level playing field. In any case, the negativity tore away at her confidence and she wound up dumping her soulful signature trills for something more conventional, which degraded her last performance.



    Poor Sabrina! She did not deserve to go home, especially humiliating opposite Haley (Who?). I didn’t think Sabrina’s last performance was up to (her) par, but it wasn’t THAT BAD.



    Sundance – A really strange situation. Sundance seemed to be more buoyed up because of mentioning his father’s accomplishments than anything else. I think it proved the judges are highly influenced by hype. Even during precontest selections, Simon told Paula he thought she was being very generous allowing Sundance to make it to the finals. I wonder how far Sundance would have gotten if he never mentioned his father (or at least never made such a big deal out of it). Guess we'll never know.



    As for Sanjaya—hey I still haven’t gotten over Sucky Bucky lasting so long. At least Sanjaya went back to his natural hairstyle instead of that silly silky look. He’s beginning to morph into Michael Jackson!moreless

Trivia, Notes, Quotes and Allusions

FILTER BY TYPE

More
Less