I liked most of it. Brooke and Jason were disasters. Over all I think only Syesha picked the right song for her. In case anyone questions my credentials in this area, I have over 10 years experience in musical theatre.
These would've been my choices for them.
David Archuleta - Music of the Night.
Jason Castro - Any dream will do
David Cook - The Lady's Got Potential
Syesha Mercado - I agreed with her pick but I would've prefered to hear her sing "Memory".
Carly Smithson - Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again
Brooke White - With one look
But I did enjopy seeing Idol do a show like this, I hope they do Sondhiem next year.